Commentary on Revelation
2. This storm being by discovered enemies, Satan cometh not so good speed; he assayeth, next, the corrupting of government, by removing of which, he might have fair access to what he pleased or intended to bring in afterward. To effectuate this, he inflameth the Church-men with pride, and from it, for precedency, wakeneth contention (as once he did amongst the Apostles) whereby the work of God was much retarded, and poor souls stumbled, and the Ordinances of Christ (especially government) corrupted. Who would see this, may read Plessaeus mystery of iniquity about the four hundred year, and what dealing there was with the east Church and falsifying of votes of Synods, as that of Nice, proven from authentic Copies, for that end, sought and found by the fathers of Africa, may be seen, C • nt. Magdeburg ; yea, also in Baronius. This prevaileth, the mountain taketh fire, and becometh low in its grandeur and spiritual weight and credit, and all are infected with this, to be more about outward pomp than inward power, about earthly thing • more than spiritual. This is the second trumpet.
3. The devil, (having prevailed this much by Church-men) setteth on, next, to poison fountains and rivers which men drink of and live upon; Doctrines were somewhat clear before, and fundamentals were not easily overthrown while government and unity were in force, Now he poisoneth sound Doctrine in the mouths of Ministers; and free-will, Justification by good works and external holiness, merit, dispensations, pennances, purgatory, sacraments, opus operatum, especially traditions, are brought in: whereby the wholesome Word was corrupted in many places of the world, and its native purity lost; and instruments were made use of in this, who once seemed to shine in the Church, as Pelagius, Origen. &c. This is the third trumpet.
4. In the fourth trumpet, the light is further obscured, and the beauty of pure Doctrine in the Church darkened, the Scripture is veiled and keeped up, ignorance fostered, tradition is brought in place of Scripture, will-worship and ceremonies for the practice of holy duties, &c. whereby the glorious light of the Gospel and of the Church was darkened and grew dim, making way for Antichrists rising, though it increased much more under him, yet even then men were more taken up with Monkishnesse and these toys, than with things which were more profitable, out of which darkness Antichrist at last start up, and took it on him, in the fifth trumpet: whereupon followeth Mahomet in the sixth, as his and the worlds scourge, until the vials make a turn, and this height of Antichrist be brought down even as he rose; which series of the vials, begineth with the seventh trumpet.
This series agreeth well with the types and also with the truth of the event in the matter of fact, as afterward succeeded, and so the Church is wasted, blasted, and way made for Antichrist by th • se first four; and therefore there can be no unwarrantablenesse in speaking thus of them. It agreeth also well with the scope, in showing Antichrists rise by these steps: Only, take that advertisement which we gave on the seals, That though there be an order in the rise of these things one after another, yet neither would we be peremptory in timing it, or ascribing it to particular events, nor yet think, that one endeth, or goeth away, when the other cometh; nay, they continue together, and do complete the Churches darkening, as it was with the dispensations under the seals; the first continued till the last, but had order in its rising, so here. And though something of the latter trumpets might be working, even as soon as the former, and no doubt the fifth began to work soon, yet the trumpet looketh at such a thing in a height or its discovery, and so the second was working under the first, but did not break out till the first was some length proceeded.
We come now particularly to the Angels sounding. The first foundeth in this seventh Verse, Where we are to consider, beside the sounding, these three things, 1. The judgment threatened, or the sign of it, fire and hail mingled with blood ; a very great storm. 2. Its object, the earth. 3. The effect, the third part of trees and all green grass was burnt up : it is like it alludeth to one of the plagues of Egypt, whereby much desolation was wrought; here it signifieth a spiritual storm, called hail, partly, because of its cold, blasting and terrible nature, especially in these Countries, it being the great cause of barrenness and unfruitfulness then; partly, because of the hurtfulness of it; so it signifieth that which heresy (in general) floweth from and carrieth with it, to wit, coldness in practice of Religion towards God, and affection towards others, making men cold within, and barren and unfruitful without; but this hail is more than an ordinary blast and storm, coming impetuously, though not lasting long. 2. There is fire, in terrible tempests, they were mixed; and this signifieth the rent of unity in practice and affection by contention and passion, as the former the defacing of Doctrine by some terrible Error. So, Luk. 12.42. I came to send fire on the earth, and James 3. it is said, the tongue is set on fire and kindleth others. This fire of division, is a companion of heresy; and heresies do often more hurt to the Church by their contentions and schisms than by their Doctrines, it being the kindling of this fire that in the judgment of many denominateth one an Heretic, which he would not be by his simple adhering to an Error, if nothing were of this. As also it is observable, that hail, which is cold, hath fire with it, like Ephraim, Hos. 7.8. who was like an unturned cake, hot beneath, and cold affections above, these go together, much zeal in an erroneous opinion and heat for that, which is ever accompanied with coldness in more fundamental things; the colder men be in the one, the hotter are they in the other, as the Pharisees were for their own traditions, zealous, but in God's commands indifferent. 3. It is mingled with blood : which holdeth out the bloody nature of heresy and of this meaned here; which we think rather to be understood of their putting faithful opposers to suffering for withstanding their Doctrine, than their suffering for it: this also is a fruit of the fiery spirit, that when words prevail not, and their falsehood is discovered, they run to open violence; and their is no cruelty like this of Heretics.
2. The object of this judgment, is, the earth, And 3. the effects, are, the burning up a third part of trees and all green grass.
1. By earth, we understand, 1. either indefinitely the visible Church, which is set upon and defaced in its most clear and plain truths, Chap. 7.1. Or, 2. more especially, the foundations of it, such truths as are most solidly to be believed, without which the visible Church cannot stand, as that, concerning the Person, Natures and Offices of the Son of God, as the earth in the Pagan world, Chap. 6. and in the Antichristian world, Chap. 16. may and doth signify their foundations, and what seemed most strong in them, and essential to them, when their foundations were shaken they must fall; so here the right confession of Christ and pure Doctrine of Faith in Him, is called the foundation or rock on which the Church is built, Mat. 16. Or, Thirdly, it may show the spreading of this plague, or sore, over the very face of the Church in respect of its extent, there being no part of the earth free of it.
3. The burning up of trees and all green grass holdeth forth, 1. The dreadful effects of this judgment on eminent professors, some for gifts and knowledge; some it may be for grace, and withal, some eminent for place and authority, called trees, as taler and stronger than others; and upon all grass, as if an utter barrenness followed it, and a pleasant land were turned to a burnt-up wilderness, that nothing almost was free from the hurt of that plague. 2. Yet it is limited, and a third part but of trees burnt up; many eminent men are keeped free.
Now, if we come to particular application of it, it is done, 1. (as some think) in respect of temporal judgments on the Empire, which in this time followed by the Goths, Vandals, &c. 2. As others think, in respect of particular heresies, to wit, of the Arians, Macedonians, Nestorians, Pelagians, &c. Or, 3. as others, in respect of Antichrists rise, as something creept in, tending to his bringing forth in the Church by several steps. But, 4. They may be generally applied to the state of the Church in such a time under them all; (yet, • looking more especially to some remarkable particular) which we think safest, Because it is most comprehensive, and yet not inconsistent with, but agreeth best to the scope, series, and order, and to the effect) it showeth the d • clissi •• state of the Church in respect of time, which also hath its tendency to Antichrists heightening. For, 1. Heresy maketh way for him who still was fishing in troubled waters; and Rome, by its Authority and outward greatness, had too much influence in these debates, as an Umpire amongst dissentients. 2. The Empires diminishing proved a taking him out of the way, which withheld, and so made still a more open door for, his rising, 2 Thess. 2.
Yet we think the Arian heresy, and what followed, accompanied and depended on it, is especially holden forth by this first trumpet: and we account the Macedonian heresy a branch of the same, for these reasons, 1. Because this change and danger of the Church by it, was so great, that it is not like other storms would be mentioned, and this past in silence; and no other place can be assigned so pertinent for it. 2. It agreeth and suiteth well with the series and time of this storm, which is the first after that calm the Church had in Constantine's time.
3. The nature of it agreeth with it, 1. It was violent, and that against the most substantial and fundamental points of Religion, to wit, the Godhead of Christ and of the holy Ghost, without which, there can be no Christianity, this being the rock upon which the Christian Church is built, Mat. 16. And there was never more fire nor blood in a storm; the Church was undone with contention, so that no general Synod (even that of Nice ) could remove it, but they burst out more; and Constantine's sad regrates and serious • xpostulations with Bishops because of this, and the many contrary Synods (some whereof sided with Arius ) confirm it.
4. Much blood and persecution followed thereupon by Constantius, Valens, and other Arian Emperors and Governors (beside what was committed by the Vandals in Africa ) than which was there never persecution more cruel and barbarous.
5. There were not only many, but exceeding eminent men, both Civil and Ecclesiastic, led away with that Error; sundry Emperors, as Constantius, Valens, before named; many Kings of the Goths and Vandals, were favorers of it; many Bishops of great r •• e in the Church, did propagate it; yea, sometimes whole Synods of many hundreds, did establish it and condemn the truth, and the defenders thereof, as that Synod at Tyre, Anno 336. did condemn Athanasius under pretext of turbulency, murder and adultery. A Synod at Antioch, Anno 337. deposed Eustachius the Bishop thereof, under the like pretexts. Such was the Council of Milan, Anno 354. (at which it is written, that Constantine being now aged, was present) which did condemn many worthy men because they would not subscribe to the condemnation of Athanasius, such were Hilarius, Osius, Paulinus, &c. Another was at Syrmia, where Osius was whipped till he did subscribe. The great Council, (for number being accounted 1000. Bishops) met at Ariminum and Seleucium, did at last establish this Doctrine, and decree that the word 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 (whereby Christ is signified to be God, of the same Essence with the Father) should be laid aside, and the word 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 (whereby is signified that He is not of the same, but of the like substance or Essence) was brought in. In which two words, though there be little difference in letters, yet much in substance, concerning which there was much debate in these days. After Macedonius arose, a third word was brought in by His followers in the place of both, to wit, 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 , whereby he would neither call Christ of the same substance and Essence with the Father, as the Orthodox did; nor of the like substance or Essence to the Father, as the Arians did (who did therefore in that Synod of Syrmia condemn Photinus for asserting Christ to be a mere man and not God, as they did Osius for asserting Him to be God co-essential with the Father) but simply to be like the Father, without mentioning either the unity or likeness of His Essence.
6. Many eminently Godly men were out of infirmity at last (by the violence of persecution) brought to subscribe to their way, and to condemn Athanasius, as did Liberius Bishop of Rome, and the foresaid Osius Bishop of Corduba, &c. who long had suffered for the truth and afterward came to the acknowledgement of it.
7. This storm, and the defection under it, became so universal, that almost all the world was become Arian, that it became a proverb, Totus mundus factus est Arianus ; and Jerome saith in Chronicis, omnes pene toto or be Ecclesiae, nomine pacis & Regis, Arianorum consortio polluuntur.
8. Then brake in the barbarous Nations, Goths and Vandals ; and the Religion they had was Arian, both in Kings of Italy and Africa, though some of them were more civil to the Church than others.
9. This contributed much to the rising of Rome, 1. Many distressed men, as Athanasius, and others, because that Church was long pure and in Authority (when others were infected and less able to help) made address to it, to implore their help for vindicating them, and the truth they maintained, by owning it and interposing for it; also Heretics when they were condemned, appealed to Rome, to draw them on their side, as Eutyches, Donatus, and sundry others in Africa which the Bishop of Rome made use of to encroach on others. 2. Some acts of Synods were made to prevent unjust oppression of honest men from corrupt Bishops which abounded in the East, during the intervalls of Synods, whereby too great weight of hearing differences for that time was drawn from the east to the w • st, a • being more free of that corruption, which was Hosius overture in the Council of Sardic • , Anno 347. which was occasioned from the overspreading of Arianis • in the east, even after the Council of Nice : from all this, Rome took much advantage. 3. By the Emperors too much liberality, they grew to pride; and by the diminishing of the Emperors Authority in the west, the Bishops of Rome grew: so that what pride, covetousness and usurpation this age brought forth in them, may be seen at large in Pless • us mystery, pag. 4.44. C • ntur. Magdeburg. C • nt. 4. by all which they did wind themselves someway in to be Umpires or Arbitrators of differences in other Churches, which afterward they drew to a debt and obligation on them. 4. At that time he being desired, did interpose brotherly by his Commi •• ioners with other Bishops and Churches; which being for a cause, upon the matter, good, and from an eminent Bishop, had much weight with it, and was much esteemed and regarded, though not as Authoritative, which his successors abused in after tim • s. So then the Churches estate betw • xt the 300. and 400. years and thereabout, will be found, as its here foretold to be. Inwardly the Church, undone by Heretics, heresies, contentions, backed with pretended Authority Civil and Ecclesiastic. The Bishops of Rome working their Supremacy in all these troubles, and he taking occasion to insinuate himself as Moderator among them, though yet under ground, and that but on the earth and low. Doctrine began even then to be in many things corrupted by special men in the Church, especially concerning freewill, ceremonies, &c. By which may be gathered, what great storm this was, and how answerable to this type; so that its easily applied to it. Observe,
1. In general, what a terrible thing it is to have error, heresy, division and contention letten louse on a Church; it is terrible as fire, hail and blood, and terrible in the effects, a third part of the trees and grass are burnt up: few believe this • yet these plagues are less terrible to bodies than error and the effects of it are to souls. 2. See the nature of heresy, 1. It is violent, cooling love, and obstructing practice whereby the soul is kept in life, but in contentions for itself and things belonging to itself, firy, bloody and cruel. The first word looketh at the impurity of the Doctrine, striking at the very foundation, • ail. The second word, fire, looketh at the breaking of unity. The third word, blood, looketh at the destroying of lives; such were the false teachers of old, such were they in Christ's time and after His time. 2. It spreadeth on many for number, on great men and good men sometime for quality, all green grass and a third part of trees. Who would have thought so many famous able men would have been carried away with it, that (as we said before) it became a proverb, the world is become Aria • ; many Bishops and Synods, many eminent in parts, partly through terror, partly through weakness, came to verbal acknowledgement of the error, and to condemn some honest men that spoke for truth? This should make us be watchful and humble: would a • y think that the God-head of Christ or of the holy Ghost should be denied? and yet this is of late revived: for, the S • c • nian error is the same in substance, and hath many followers. 3. Many trees are spared, partly as a testimony against others, partly to give themselves time to repent, they are not taken away altogether. Let us arm against such a storm and become more warrie and watchful.
LECTURE III.
Vers. 8.
And the second Angel sounded, and as it were a great mountain burning with fire was cast into the sea, and the third part of the sea became blood:
9.
And the third part of the creatures which were in the sea, and had life, died, and the third part of the ships were destroyed.
YE may remember when we began to speak of this prophesy of the trumpets, we told you that in them was contained the story of the Church from the int • rrupting of the peace that it enjoyed under Constantine till Antichrist was at his height, and God by pouring out of the vials came to demolish his Kingdom.
The prophesy of the • e trumpets is divided in smaller and greater woes, the last three being the greatest.
The first four do continue the History of the Church from the peace it enjoyed under the sixth seal unto the discovery of Antichrist upon his seat and throne.
Ye heard, in the former trumpet, how hard the condition of the Christian Church was, and by what means it was weakened, 1. By outward inbreaking of cruel barbarous Nations, merciless enemies, to the defacing of it. 2. By enemies from within, such as Arians, Macedonians, N • storians, and also Schismatics, as Luciferians, Novatians, A • daeans, &c. that would not keep unity, as the former would not keep purity. 3. By corrupting of the Doctrine, many unsafe and unsound Doctrines attended with pernicious practices, were creeping in amongst famous men in the Church. 4. It was also weakened by contention • and ambition amongst Bishops and Ministers for their precedency: out of all which, Satan's design of raising Rome, and bringing in Ant • christ, was woe • king, and took rooting, springing and spreading itself more and more till it came to the height. We shall say no more of the first trumpet, but proceed to the rest.
This second trumpet advanceth and carrieth on the same scope: and if any ask, why these trumpets blow not together, and yet one succeedeth another? I answer, there is some interim, to see how the former may work; and if any will repent, God taketh that time of trial. 2. When it worketh not, a greater cometh, then He plagueth seven times more: there are degrees even of spiritual judgments, Rom. 1. When alarms work not, there are worse coming.
For opening the meaning of this sad judgment, we must consider in it these three things, 1. The mean made use of, or the rise of the judgment, it was as a mountain burning. 2. Its object, it is cast into the sea. 3. The effects that follow upon it, the waters became blood, and many ships are destroyed. Generally, it showeth that this judgment extended further than the former, 1. The former was on the land only; this taketh in the sea. 2. It altereth quite the nature of these seas; the former destroyed but trees and grass that were growing, This is more infectious.
1. It is said, as it were a great mountain, to show it was something figuratively to be understood and not properly, like a hill, such as Aetna in Sicily, or Hecla in Island, are, which burneth within itself, and dissolveth itself.
By mountains in Scripture, are understood figuratively Powers or Authorities, Zech. 4.7. Who art thou, O great mountain? before Z • rubbabel thou shalt become a plain. He meaneth the opposition of that Monarchy which then oppressed them. Ier. 51.25. Babylon is called a destroyed mountain, and a mountain that shall be made a burnt mountain : So by mountain here we understand eminent men in the Church and her Authority, or these placed in Authority in her, who by their place are eminent above others; it being the Church here that especially is spoken of, this mountain must be their Judicatories and these in power. Therefore the Disciples, and in them Ministers, are said to be as a city set on a mountain, or hill, Matth. 5. these being mountains for eminency in the Church, as civil Governors, or Governments are in the State. 2. This mountain is said to be burning ; which we conceive to be kindled with pride, and contention flowing therefrom, as Christ saith, He came to send fire on the earth, and it was already kindled, which is to be expounded variances amongst these in nearest relations: so also fire, it is taken for contention in Jotham's parable, Judge. 9. compare verse. 20. with verse. 23. which is the more clear here, that it followeth upon the former trumpet, as taking fire from it, and it seemeth to be the Church-Governors that were kindled by it. This fire having kindled within their bowels, breaketh out and infecteth others and spreadeth this division under this trumpet at the back of the former heresy and sad state which the Church was in, having to do not only with open Heretics, but with pride and contention amongst Church-men themselves, whereby exceedingly the Church was wronged, and way was made for the in-bringing of more corruption and Antichrists rising.
2. The object, it is cast into the sea, 1. By the sea, in Scripture among the Prophets, is understood a numerous people, as, to fit on many waters, Revel. 17.15. By this then we are to understand, that though this infection began among the Church-men, yet was it cast in the sea, that is, spread far off amongst the people. So it was in this time, and so it useth to be. 2. By sea, is understood in Scripture, Nations beyond seas; often the west part of the world, because they were by the sea divided from Judea, as by the earth or land is understood the east par • , Isa. 60.5, &c. and thus it may well here look to Rome, Africa and the west, upon which this storm mainly did fall, as the first did fall on the Church in the east chie • lie, which was called the earth. 3. By sea, in this prophesy, is understood the Ordinances, in Discipline, Worship, and Government of the Church, and exercises of Religion, because in these, and by these, Christians in this World of the Church do converse together, traffic one with another, communicate one with another, as men do by seas and ships, who other ways are at a distance. So, ( Chap. 18.) in the Antichristian world, their Church-men are compared to men in ships, or Merchants, who (amongst other things) trade for men's souls, which can be meaned of no other but their Church-men, verse. 15. and their going about their superstitions, is compared to trading in Ships and Seas: Whereby it would appear, that here especially a storm upon Ordinances, Worship and Discipline, is signified, as in the former, the Doctrine was set upon; yet Discipline and Councils were in some vigor, both having some Authority from without by Constantine, unity and respect from within, as at Nice, soundness and solidity in proceeding; but in the succeeding ages, all was changed. First, Emperors became Arians, Councils became heterodox, unity was broken, partly by Schisms amongst themselves, partly by the Pelagians and Donatists, which at this time came to a height: separation from Churches, flowing from pride, under the pretext of the unholiness of the Churches Members, began and continued long, troubling especially the west part of the world, which formerly was free, and the preaching of the Word was foisted with human inventions by men who were not Heretics, the government of the Church spoiled, broken, dissolved and burnt; pride consumeth all and maketh it contemptible. So it is said of Babylon, Jer. 21.25. I will make thee a burnt mountain, when the dissolution of her authority is prophesied of.
3. The effects of this mountains casting in the sea, recorded here, are two, the one the effect of the other, 1. The waters are turned into blood, showing they were corrupted; that being the great evidence of corruption in them, alluding to the plague of Egypt, Exod. 7.19. which showeth, that by that foregoing rent, Discipline was weakened, Ordinances corrupted, and the nature of them altered; they were before useful, now they are hurtful, as being abused by this firy mountains falling into them. So the Synods, Councils and Ministry in many places became such as were rather for destruction than edification, and Churches were rent and divided, and stumblings laid before poor people, whereby the second effect followed, that is, as in waters turned to blood, fishes cannot live, so by these errors in Doctrine and Worship (which both now continue together) poor souls are destroyed, simplicity of Worship corrupted with ceremonies and traditions, and all Church men, almost, who trade in these ships, are undone and destroyed with this ambition; for, blood signifieth any death, even spiritual death, Ezek. 3.18. His blood will I require of thee, &c. which is His spiritual killing of them; and here we are to understand their being killed with self-seeking and pride, and so to be dead while they were alive, 1 Tim. 5.6. and deadly to others also. In sum then, by the second trumpet we are to understand the corruption of the Government and Governors, who heightening their places beyond Christ's order, and exercising that power, not for edification, but for destruction (contrary to its nature) in fiery contentions flowing from their pride and ambition, by which the eminency of the Church in that respect was dissolved in its Authority, and became low (as a mountain doth, which is consumed by fire from within) whereby many dreadful effects tending both to the wronging of the Ordinances of Jesus Christ, and exceeding hurtful to all the members of the Church who lived under them, were brought to pass, and so the Churches life (as it were) brought into greater hazard, than under open Heretics.
For application of this, we will find it suit well with the contentions that followed on the Council of Nice, and then burst out amongst Church-men, exceeding hurtfully unto the Church: for clearing whereof, we may observe these things from the story of that time, 1. Divisions and contentions abounded, as is clear from the many complaints of Emperors and Fathers, especially Gregori •• Nax. who therefore took a prejudice at Councils, because so much contention followed that of Nice.
As also by the many contrary Synods and contests for precedency in them among Churchmen, who continued till the Bishop of Rome carried away the title of Universal Bishop, as will appear more under the fifth trumpet. 2. The time of these contentions will agree to this; for, this fire of pride was kindled, and the foundation laid for carrying on these contests to that height from the former heresy; some acts were made, whereby some Bishops, especially they of Rome, were preferred to others, because they were more free of that infection, and were more able to help the truth and these who were persecuted for it in the East, as particularly that seventh canon at Serdica, overtured by Osius for that end, from which Rome took advantage afterward. 3. In these Councils upon this occasion the precedency of some Seas was established, and a foundation of the Ecclesiastic hierarchy was laid. First, The Council of Nice appointed four Patriarchs, at Alexandria in Egypt, at Antioch in Asia, at Jerusalem in Syria, at Rome in the West, over all Metrapolitans, who yet were independently of equal Authority within their own bounds, as is clear, Can. 6. Secondly, After that Rome was preferred in order to the rest, and Constantinople made second, not by any dignity of these Seas, but because they were the seats of the imperial Authority, as appeareth from Can. 3. of the second Council at Constantinople, confirmed, Can. 28. of the Council at Chalcedon, and the 36. Can. of the Council at Trulos, where Constantinople is made second to Rome, because it was new Rome, and had the same civil privileges with old Rome : which showeth the reason why both these Seas were preferred, was built merely upon civil privileges, which also Balsamon upon the foresaid canons confirmeth from Justinian's Laws, Novel 130. 4. Rome took much occasion to plead its supremacy, partly from these constitutions, partly from the practice of men who still endeavored to have that Bishop on their side as a great help to their party, and therefore fled to it for succor whether they maintained Truth or Error; partly, from this, that their interposing had great weight with others upon the former considerations, which they endeavored afterward to impose upon other Churches as of due belonging to them, and therefore first opposed that act whereby Constantinople was equal to them, and afterward pleaded for appeal unto themselves from the Churches of the East and in Africa, as appeareth by their letters to the Council of Antioch, and their propositions made in the Council of Chalcedon, but more especially by their ambassages and letters to the Council of Carthage, where these things are observable,
1. That one Apiarius, Bishop of Sica, justly censured by a former Council at Carthage, did appeal to the Bishop of Rome. 2. Three Bishops of Rome, Zosimus, Boniface, Caelestinus, one after another, did so far own that appeal, as to admit the sentenced person to their communion, and to send Faustinus and others their Ambassadors to the sixth Council of Carthage (where were convened 217. Bishops, among which was Augustine, and Aurelius Bishop of Carthage, who presided, and is called Pope by Balsamon ) desiring the former sentence to be repealed. 3. They grounded their interposing in these matters upon the Council of Nice ; some pretended acts whereof, their Commissioner Faustinus produced, wherein it was alleged to be decreed that a Bishop in any place might appeal to the Bishop of Rome. 4. It is observable that these Fathers acknowledged no such act, neither was there any such found amongst the canons of the Council at Nice which any of them had seen, and therefore did suspect the design of the Roman Bishop, as aiming to stretch his power too far; whereupon they directed messengers to the Bishops of Antioch, Canstantinople and Alexandria, for obtaining authentic and unsuspected copies of the canons of the said Council, which afterward they received from Cyrillus Bishop of Alexandria, and Atticus Bishop of Constantinople, without any such acts in them for Rome's Authority, as was alleged.
It is true, this supremacy was not pleaded from any divine institution (which at that time they did pretend unto) but only upon Ecclesiastic constitution; it is true also that whatever privileges Rome claimed by Constantine's donation, or any canons of the Council of Nice and Serdica, are also attributed unto Constantinople by the Councils of Constantinople and Chalcedon, whereby its Authority and privileges are every way equal to Rome in things Ecclesiastic, as it was equal to it in Civil things by the Emperors Laws; so that appeals were as warrantable to Constantinople as to Rome (as Balsamon also upon the former Councils allegeth; and therefore showeth the privileges of Constantinople and its Bishop out of the gift of Constantine, as it is called, to the Bishops of Rome. ) 3. It is also clear, that there was no just ground, even from Ecclesiastic constitutions, for that which was pretended, and that these Fathers foresaid did neither credit the Bishop of Rome in asserting his own Authority, nor yet cede to him in the least measure when they had evidenced his allegiance to be false; but, on the contrary, maintained their own Authority to be independent of him, and therefore do enact that from thenceforth none of their number should appeal beyond Sea, (to wit, to Rome ) Can. 31. and that none should cite another of their number thither, Can. 126. under pain of Excommunication; and did write back to Boniface, and after to Caelestin ( Zosimus being dead ere the answer from Egypt returned) expostulating with them for the marring them in the exercise of their due Authority, and pleading that none, censured by them, should be heard by him, or received into communion with him; and did also refuse to louse the sentence of the foresaid Ap • arius (whereupon he afterward left his dependency on the Bishop of Rome and submitted to his own Synod) I say, though these things be true, and it might be thought that the supremacy of Rome had no great advantage from them, yet from this we may see that Church-authority was abused by the pride of Church-men, even at that time; and that, upon the occasion of the former heresy, grounds were laid, from which the Bishops of Rome drew encouragements to prosecure their supremacy, and upon which they continued to build it up, till it came to its height; for, still there were debates about it, especially between them and the Bishop of Constantinople (who, in the Emperor Maurice his time, assumed first to himself the title of Universal Bishop and precedency beyond Rome, because then the Emperor lived at Constantinople ) until Antichrist was discovered. By which we may see, how hurtful that contention was to the Church, and how far it contributed in the event of it for the advancing of Antichrist, which is the main plague intended in these trumpets, and therefore not unsuitably taken-in under this second trumpet, as being agreealbe with the scope, type, time, and other reasons alleged in the application of the former trumpet,
Observe, 1. What an evil thing pride is, especially when it entereth among Church-men: O how evil a thing is it! it is the inlet of all confusion, it openeth a door to it and every evil work, and hath a special hand in overturning of whatsoever is beautiful in a Church, James 3.14, 16. Therefore it is no wonder Satan seek to destroy government and unity, when he would destroy a Church; and no wonder Christ so much commend humility and unity to his followers. 2. The more eminent folks be in place or power, they are the • ooner kindled with the fire of pride; the higher men's places be, they are the readier to grow proud; mountains sooner than valleys, men of gifts sooner than others, they have fuel to this fire that others do want, and are more obnoxious to blasts; partly, the things being excellent they have in their hand; and partly, they being eminently and highly planted, pride hath the more matter to work upon, and Satan hath the readier access, and occasion to blow them up; it is a rare thing to be eminent and humble; to be great and in prosperity, and yet to be lowly: prosperity and gifts are a snare to many; it had been advantage to many they had never had them, considering how they have been abused by their pride and other corruptions. 3. Pride is especially incident to Church-men: which might be cleared both in the Old and New Testament. They are as cities set on an hill, Mat. 5. The Church is a mountain that is eminent, and Church-governors are eminent above others; and therefore liable to maniest temptations, being about the most eminent things, the devil setteth on them most, knowing what advantage he hath, when he hath gained ground among them, and Christ had to do even with His Disciples in this, Matth. 18. verse. 20.4. It is a great plague and judgment, and bringeth great hurt to the Church: when this fire of pride and, contention entereth and kindleth among the Officers of the Church, it spreadeth, marret • , and corrupteth all; it is the rise of much ill, and abusing of the power that God hath given: Diotrephes, loving the preeminencie, put all in confusion; it began soon in John's days, 3 Epist. John. and it is opposed to receiving of the Gospel, and accounting of the Apostles. This is no matter of laughing to you, however ye look upon it as if ye were not concerned; no, it is your plague, as if a firy mountain were tumbled-over on you. This should make us all respect unity and peace in the Church, and watch against pride and contention that marreth it. 5. There are four ills in this text that follow on pride and contention among Church-men, 1. It weakeneth and bringeth down Church-authority; when this mountain taketh fire, it falleth. 2. It spreadeth, infecteth, and kindleth others, it goeth among the people, I am of Paul, and I'am of Apollos, and they become carnal and factious, 1 Cor. 1.12. and 3.1, 2. and the life of Religion is eaten out amongst them, seeing from the Priests profaneness spreadeth through the whole land, Ier. 23. and so do pride and contention; kindle the Officers, and the whole Church will be in a fire. If we looked on it rightly, we would think the rise of contention a terrible plague, and people would beware of adding fuel to this fire, and labor by all means to quench it; because it is hard to know where it may end. 3. It corrupteth all, first, the Doctrine; secondly, the Practice; thirdly, Discipline and Order, and then cometh confusion and every evil work. 4. Many are stumbled and Spiritually slain when these waters become blood; so that corrupting of Government and Governors is no small judgment, whereby we may know why Satan aimeth so much at this, and why we ought to be the more watchful against it.
6. This plague, or stroke, on the Church, doth often accompany a spirit of error and defection, partly succeeding it, partly going before it, either causally inferred, or at least occasioned, or in God's righteous judgment trysted with it, that the trial may have the greater extent and efficacy to discover many Hypocrites and rotten Professors. Tremble to think on it, and adore God's holy Justice in the measure it is met out to us in our time; when the outward mean of Discipline and Government is so weakened, there had need to be the more watchfulness and dependency on God to be helped and sustained by Him, when outward means are not so frequent nor in such vigor as they wont to be.
LECTURE IIII.
Vers. 10.
And the third Angel sounded, and there fell a great Star from heaven burning as it were a lamp, and it fell upon the third part of the rivers, and upon the fountains of waters:
11.
And the name of the Star is called Worm-wood, and the third part of the waters became wormwood, and many men died of the waters, because they were made bitter.
THe Church being before defaced by gross Heretics and Errors, and kindled within by pride and contention: for, the Government amongst its Governors, is now set upon by another mean, the rivers and fountains that were a little clear before, and these streams whereby the waters of life were conveyed, are made biter, and, instead of life, they convey death by being now corrupted.
In this trumpet we are to consider these three, 1. The judgment or ill that followed the Angels sounding. 2. The cause, I mean the instrumental cause, or rise of it, whence it flowed. 3. The effects of it.
1. The judgment or ill, is, The corrupting of a third part of the waters, fountains and rivers. By fountains and rivers (which are the object) are understood the Doctrines of the Gospel, or the Covenant of Grace and Christ's Offices, and the way of conveying and communicating the same to sinners by the Ordinances of the visible Church, called the wells of salvation, Isa. 12.3. and called springs, or well-springs, which God hath placed in His Church, and which are nowhere else, Psal. 87. ult. because th ••• , and by it, the righteousness of God is revealed from Faith to Faith, Rom. 1.17. And in E • eki • ls vision these waters are said to stream and flow from under the altar, and out of the Sanctuary, Ezek. 47.1, &c. and may well be compared to fountains, as the Church is called ( Cant. 4.) A spring shut up, a fountain sealed, and a fountain of Gardens, because of these waters springing in it, and because of the nature of them, which is clear, single, sweet and refreshing, as useful and necessary to spiritual life, as waters are to the bodily; and as having that use in the religious world, (which this is) which waters have in the natural; and also in respect of the manner of dispensing Grace in the Gospel so largely and so freely, wherefore it is compared to an open fountain to all Nations, Zech. 13.1. and so, frequently folks are invited to drink freely, Isa. 55.1. and Rovel. 22.17. and to wash. By rivers, we understand the preaching and dispensing of this Gospel, whereby it is holden forth, and (as it were) floweth to others: which two, are often put together, when the spreading of the Gospel is prophesied of, I will open rivers in the wilderness and fountains in the deser • , Isa. 41.17.18. probably referring to the spreading of the Gospel amongst the Gentiles: so, corrupting of this word, is compared to mixing of liquor with something that is not of its kind, nor so good, as Vintners do adulterat wine, 2 Cor. 2.17. opposit to the single and pure preaching of Christ which Paul used.
2. The instrumental cause of this which maketh the waters bitter, is set out three ways, 1. It is more generally called a Star, and a great Star, burning like a lamp. 2. It is shown from whence this Star fell. 3. And more particularly, the name of the Star is called Wormwood.
By Stars (as we heard, Chap. 1. verse. 20.) are understood Ministers in the visible Church, who, by receiving light from Christ, should hold it forth to others: a great Star burning like a Lamp, is, one eminent for parts, gifts, place, or in estimation for holiness, making a great show, yet not having much reality, but (as it were) a glancing counterfeit light, no • proceeding from a right principle, as that of the Stars doth from the Sun, but kindled from some external thing as that of a Lamp is, nor so solid as the former, though having more glorious and pompous appearance. 2. This Star fell from Heaven, that is, made defection from the visible Church and the straight and pure preaching of the Gospel, and corrupted these fountains and waters; Error bringeth folks low, even from Heaven to Earth, as prof • nity doth; when this wild-fire of self-seeking is by pride kindled, and by parts and gifts without grace entertained, it soon bringeth down the greatest Star that taketh not its light from Christ. The word is, it was falling, not altogether fallen, as is spoken, Chap. 9.1. to signify a begun decay, or fall, which afterward John discerned more clearly when it was fallen and come to its height, or rather lowness of a full decay: by it is shown, that this plague is promoved by such as by their parts or former estimation have been eminent in the Church.
3. The name of the Star, is, Wormwood, given him from the effect which it produceth, it having influence to corrupt the sweetest things and to make them partake of its nature. Deut. 29.18. It is spoken of a man that hath a root that beareth gall or wormwood, one that walked not straightly by God's rule: and Act. 8.23. Simon Magus lo said to be in the gall of bitterness for his corrupt thoughts of the grace of God; and it may well get this name, which hath so much influence upon fountains and rivers, that it may make them bitter like wormwood, that is, altereth their swer • nature, bringing-in free will, the de • ection of the Saints, the inefficacy of Grace, the Doctrine of merit and predestination upon foreseen works, or Faith, &c. whereby the nature of the Gospel is quite overturned, and that Doctrine which was healthful to be drunken in, is now like the Prophets pottage, having death in the pot, that none who would be unpoisoned dare drink of it, more than the Egyptians might drink of their rivers when they were turned into blood.
It is said to fall on a third part of the waters ; either, 1. Because it was not a full defection from all truth, some were by God's goodness keeped clear. Or, 2. That this gross error, or this heresy, though it spread far, yet it did not infect all men; some prime men and Churches were keeped free of it. Or, 3. De • ection in these truth • was • ot then at its height, but growing. The effect is, many men died, &c. which is to be understood of spiritual and eternal death, following on the former corruptions, by which many were destroyed, like that which is mentioned in the former trumpet.
To come to the application of this, We, 1. take it for granted, that some Church-defection is signified by this, rather than the overtturning of the civil state of the Roman Empire; for, the falling of the Roman State is not actively the cause of its own bitterness, that State being passive in its being overturned; and the bitterness floweth not from it as an agent, yet it is clear here, that this falling Star is the active agent, or instrument of imbittering these waters, as the hail and the burning mountain was in the two trumpets before: also the title Star, and the effects (as they are used in this prophesy) will agree best to Church-men and affairs, beside the scope whereof we have spoken.
2. This judgment differeth from the former two, 1. In its object; more immediately it striketh at the way of the Gospels manifesting grace. 2. In its rise; it is from some eminent preacher carrying it on with more rational eloquence, seeming reason, and pretext of holiness, or, by moe preachers together. 3. In the manner of it: not by blood, no • mixing in persecution, as the former two had waiting on them, but by making the waters bitter, turning them into wormwood, which was by the infecting of them with the error itself. 4. That it falleth not on the earth, as Chap. 9.1. because yet it was but working, and that Star not fully discovered as yet by this fall: and so here its a great Star; but ( Chap. 9.1.) a Star, only because he lost much of his splendor by the first fall, though we think it is the same fall begun here, and perfected there.
3. We take it for granted also, that this trumpet in its rise belongeth to that time that succeeded the former contentions in the Church, when the Bishops and Clergy of Rome especially, were kindling both the Churches of the East, and in Africa, for their supremacy. This will be in the fifth Century a little after the 400. year: we • may apply it generally to the state of the Church during that fifth Century, or, particularly to • ome Heretics in it: generally, Doctrine then was corrupted, not only by Pelagius, Anno 413. N • storius, 429. Eutyches, about 448. and other gross Heretics, and these errors exceedingly fomented by the powers of the world, especially that of the Eutychea • s ; by Anastasius the Emperor, and a second Council at Ephesus, called pradatoriu • , because of its • nfamous proceeding against Flavianus and in favors of E • tychet, by Dioscorus means Bishop of Alexandria ; for which it was protested against as no Synod by Anatolius, and Severus, Bishop of A • tioch. But, which is more, though there were many eminent men who stood against these Errors, yet a great decay of true Doctrine crept in amongst good men, that never did wear out again, but grew still more in the Church, to wit, about satisfaction, penance, free • -will, merit of works, possibility of fulfilling the Law, holy days, &c. This application, in this last respect, we suppose safest, as fore showing the Church, or Church-men generally to fall from true light, and to be kindled with zeal for superstitions; and though it did not in this age uniersally corrupt the Church in that height that followed, but a third part, i.e. many were keeped free; yet, way was made to it, and the Churches declining, and fall was begun, which stayed not till afterward it came to its height. This agreeth to the story, considering the Doctrine of the Church at that time; and to the scope, which showeth the Churches decay by degrees, and Antichrists gradual rise, his Doctrine (though not his Supremacy) got much footing in this age; and also with the type here. 1. of a Star falling, which we will find was fallen, Chap. 9.1. 2. It corrupteth fountains and streams, insensibly, not striking so directly at the foundation as the former particular heresies did, but keeping the Doctrine of the Trinity and Person of Christ pure, as Gregorius Roma. did, but miscarrying in the nature of His Offices, and His executing of them: it corrupteth mainly by adding unto, and mixing somewhat with truth, yet such addition as altereth the nature of them; such are the Popish additions of merits, pennances, indulgences, mediators, and intercessions of Saints, and Angels, &c. whereby that which was, is not removed, but by this addition corrupted. 3. It cometh from Stars in Heaven, and riseth more from within than the former: thus being applied, it relateth to no particular heresy, but to the general decay of the Church. If it be necessary to be applied to one, I incline to apply it to Pelagius and his heresy more than any other, for these reasons. It agreeth, 1. in the time; he began under Arcadius and Honorius, about the year 415. or according to some, 405. 2. He was of great parts, and was once thought a good zealous man, and was advanced to Ecclesiastical orders. 3. The nature of that heresy was not against Christ's Person, but His Offices, teaching corruptly of Nature, Sin, Grace, Faith, Justification, Election, &c. subtly undermyning grace. 4. It spread exceedingly through Italy, Britain, France, Africa and the eastern Empire, &c. yet, some were keeped free of it, and great Lights set themselves against it, as Augustine, Hieronymus, Prosper, Optatus, &c. 5. It entered and continued in a great measure in the Church of Rome ; and the dregs of it sticketh to the Popish Writers in their free-will, perfection of righteousness, &c. to this day: for, though the natures and person of our Lord be keeped free by them; yet their Doctrine e • ervateth His Offices, and maketh them bitter to all that would drink thereof, which are the special springs of Grace in the Gospel; they put in other satisfactions, other mediators, others with Authority, to add and diminish from what He hath commanded, other Officers to teach, and other matter to be taught, than He hath instituted, as traditions, &c. which being the rise of much Antichristian Doctrine still retained by them, it agreeth best with the scope to be thus applied. Hence,
1. See here the nature and usefulness of pure Doctrine, and what men ought to think of it, and how to use it; to drink it in as fountain water, and to wash and make clean a • it, it is as profitable to souls, and they cannot live without it; and when they want it, they want that which both purgeth and maketh them grow. Observe, 2. the ill of error; it corrupteth the Truths of the Gospel, and maketh the sweetest and best things bitter, it removeth them not professedly, but poisoneth them so, that it is better to forebear, than drink in such waters. 3. See what the nature and native office and place of Ministers is, and what advantage they are, while they keep their station; They are like Stars and great Stars, exceedingly useful and profitable in their place. And, upon the other hand, what a sore judgment and plague is it, when Ministers fall from receiving light from Christ, and are infected, they are most hurtful. 4. The moe parts and the better men's life be that are infected, they are the bitterer, and do the more wrong: as the corruption of the best things is worst, so is the corruption of eminent men, 2 Cor. 2, ult. 5. Error venteth not still after one way; now it corrupteth more subtly than it did in the former • rumpets; there is no blood nor fire here, though it be as dangerous: often, contentio • s for dominion in Government have more fire and he • t tha • dispures about more fundament • l truths. 6. There may be much glancing, false, and counterfeit light, both among Ministers and Professors, where there is little solidity: it is not all gold that glisters in them; It is good light that cometh from a right principle within; It is good when a man's works shine, as his gifts shine. This would teach us not to admire gifts; many make a fair show in the flesh, and if their light and parts were well tried by the effects, they might be called wormwood that imbittereth the waters; torches that do glance, but not Stars. Ob • . 7. That men of great gifts, fair professions and blameless lives, may fall very foully, while they are not solid and sincere, they may fall as it were from heaven, so may particular Churches: there is no state, nor degree of any state exempted when error breaketh in. Therefore the moe gifts and parts men have, they have the more need to be humble and to fear and tremble, considering many experiences both of former ages and of this, which should make us take heed lest we fall, and infect or be infected: such were once Pelagius, yea, Soci ••• , Swenk • eldius, and Arminius, thought to be. 8. Error when it infecteth Ministers, or Professors, bringeth death with it, as well as profanity; when this Star falleth from heaven, and poisoneth the waters, many die: he that teacheth men to break the least command, shall be least in the Kingdom of Heaven, Matth. 5. O that men in this time thought on this, that error bringeth to hell, as well as Adultery, that it is like rebellion and witchcraft; It is like the grossest evil, and worse; it inciteth, teacheth and encourageth to break the Commands of God, and there is much cruelty done to souls in tolerating of these. 9. The Church sustaineth no greater prejudice often, in corrupting of her Doctrine, than by the falls and slips of eminent men: these spots are hardly removed, because they sink deeper. 10. Every corruption and plague hath its degrees and steps. 11. It is a sign of a decaying Church, when eminent men fall, and it is a great judgment to others.
LECTURE V.
Vers. 12.
And the fourth Angel sounded, and the third part of the Sun was smitten, and the third part of the Moon, and the third part of the Stars, so as the third part of them was darkened: and the d • y shone not for a third part of it, and the night likewise.
13.
And I beheld, and heard an Angel flying through the midst of heaven, saying with a loud voice, Woe, woe, woe, to the inhabiters of the earth, by reason of the other voices of the trumpet of the three Angels which are yet to sound.
THe fourth Angel with his trumpet, bringeth the last of the four lesser woes (it is greater than the former, yet lesser than these that immediately ensue) which clearly doth relate to that age immediately going before Antichrists discovery, and so falleth betw • xt this time andthe sixth Century. This is set down, verse. 12. And the 13. verse. is a preface and introduction to the three great woes, which the last three Angels bring.
There are but two things mentioned in this fourth trumpet. 1. The judgment or type, it is a smiting of the third part of the Sun, Moon, and Stars. 2. The effect of this judgment, is, a following darkness suitable to it, and the day shone not for a third part of it, an • the night likewise : because the Sun that giveth light by day, and the Moon and Stars that give light by night, they were all darkened and • mitten. There is no word of any particular cause, or mean, where • by the Sun was smitten, as under the former trumpets wasmentioned. By Sun, Moon, and Stars, we understand, and comprehend under them, light of all sorts, such as is the purity of Doctrine in the Word, compared to light, Psal. 119.105. And, 2 Pet. 1.19. the word of prophesy is called a light that shineth in a dark place : and so it may be, seeing Christ who is the Sun of Righteousness shineth therein, Mal. 4. And by the spreading of the Gospel, is said to arise, for the direction and comfort of His people, (See also, Matth. 4.16.) Or also, the light of order, comliness, and a good conversation in the power of Godliness, as Phil. 2.15. and Matth. 5.17. So the Church ( Cant. 6.) is called fair, as the Moon, and the Ministers compared to Stars, and the general beauty of the Church is prophesied of in these terms, Isa. 30.26. The light of the Moon shall be as the light of the Sun, and the light of the Sun as the light of seven days : and consequently, the diminishing and contracting of these lights, must be the declining and decaying of light in the Church, both in respect of purity of Doctrine, when it is da • kened, and simplicity of Worship and Power in practice; these by human traditions and ceremonies and superstitions, are quite dimned, eclipsed and darkened. A third part is but smitten and darkened, and shineth not, which is in comparison of the total eclipse following under the fifth trumpet, when the Sun is wholly darkened, Chap. 9 verse. 1. This is higher and of larger extent than the former, yet less than these that follow in degree, but little odds in kind from the fifth. It differeth from the former as being of larger extent, affecting the Sun and light in a greater degree; also, in respect there is no particular instrument named; the reason is, because it relateth to no particular heresy, or defection, different from the former, or that which followeth, nor to no particular Heretic, but is a further and higher degree and step of that same declining, • lowing not from without, but from within, insensiblie growing by a general declining, till it come to the top in the following trumpets.
The reasons why we apply it to the sixth Century, are from considering of the story, where it is clear, that in that age light was exceedingly (though not fully) darkened: and many things remarkable suit this type, As, 1. that there was no particular heresy, nor prime heretic in all that Century, though former heresies (as that of Arius, Eutyches, &c. ) spread more, yet there was no particular heretic that arose to be instrumental in this darkening, as in the form • there was, to wit, Pelagius, Nestorius Bishop of Constantinople and Eutyches. See Cent. 6. Preface, and Cap. 1. 2. That though there was no heretic, yet there was a great and general decay of simple purity, both in Doctrine, Worship,
Government and practice (as in that Century may be seen, and in 〈…〉 Gregorius, 〈…〉 his life by Platina ) monasteries, superstitious days, doctrine of works, and traditions increased, &c. See Cent. 6. cap. 1. & 7. where the building of Abbacies, deserting of Marriages, even by Kings and Queens for devotion, is mentioned. 3. That light and knowledge was very low now in the Church; few able men are marked to have lived in this Century: which certainly showeth great decay of light, they being lights to the world: There are but two eminently marked, Fulgentius and Gregorius Magnus, who though in some things against the Arians and Eutycheans▪ &c. they do well; yet in many things their infirmity and declining from purity, especially of the last, appeareth, and yet never was there in Rome be far such a Bishop after him in any respect; he is called the worst of these, who went before him, and the best of these who followed. 4. That old heresies by that occasion did thrive well, the Eutycheans especially. 5. Anastasius the Emperor he countenanced this heresy, and though before his coronation he subscribed to the Nicean and Chalcedon faith, whereby this heresy was condemned; yet after he retracted, and became a great persecutor, banishing and cutting off many able honest Ministers, especially Euph • mius who crowned him (because he refused to give back his subscription, and would not admit him to Communicate, as infected with heresy) and also Macedonius his successor and sundry others, for not admitting the 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 he had appointed; some acriter impugnantes, alii imprudentius defendentes Concilium Nicaenum, saith the story. He would not have had that Council mentioned, because it condemned his tenent. 6. This age is remarkable from the pride and practice of John Bishop of Constantinople, who, by the consent (as it seemeth) of Maurice the Emperor, and the Bishops of the East, took on him the name of Universal Bishop and Patriarch : and what fol • lowed upon that, may be seen at large in the writings of Gregorius Bishop of Rome, Where these things are clear, 1. That there was a decay of zeal and humility amongst Bishops, by their bussying themselves in things of the world. 2. That the title of Universal Bishop, was accounted a sure mark of Antichrist, derogating from all other Bishops, as if one only were a Bishop, and a style that no Apostle, even Peter did ever assume. 3. He concluded, that Antichrist was near, seeing a Priest so exalted himself, and (which is hard to be said) he should have an Army of Priests ready to advance him: for (saith he) what is Antichrists exalting himself above all that is called god in this world, and sitting in his Temple as God, but a Priest lifting up himself above all his fellow-priests, which is to take Christ's Chair? as by considering these places is manifest, 4 Epist. 32, 34, 36, 38. ad Iohanne •• Constant. where these words are, Rex superbia prope est, & quod dici nefas est, Sacerdotum praeparatus est exercitus, quia cervici militant superbia, &c. And again, lib. 7. Epist 30. ad Mauritium Aug. Ego autem fidenter dico, quia quisque se universal • Episcopum aut Sacerdotem vocat, vel vocari desiderat in elatione suâ, Antichristum praecurrit, qui superbiendo se caeteris praeponit. And (as he said, Epist. 34. lib. 4. ad Constantiam Augustam ) he imitateth the devil in seeking to be above his Collegues. These things belonging to the same time that the series of the prophesy falleth into, and agreeing so well to the type in the Text, and to the succeeding trumpet, It seemeth clearly applicable to it, especially considering that these debates made way exceedingly for the Bishop of Rome, and his stepping up where the Bishop of Constantinople would have been, and endeavored to be.
In the 13. verse. before the fifth Angel sound, there is a little interruption made to John, to prepare him for it, An Angel flying through the midst of heaven, that is, so as he might be best heard, having a sad proclamation Woe, woe, woe, repeated thrice according to the number of the Angels that were yet to sound, that everyone of them were to bring an harder and greater woe to the men of the earth, than anything that had befallen them under the former four: and whether we take these woes, as denouncing judgment, or as lamenting over the earth for what was coming, as if he did say, Alas, alas, alas, it turneth to one thing, there were great woes coming. It is clear here, 1. That interruptions for John's clearing, are not inconsistent with this prophesy. 2. That there is an order of time in the woes of the trumpets; these three have order, and follow the former four. 3. That the next trumpet is not the Saracens ; neither do the former look m • inly to the Goths, &c. because it will appear in story, that the Empire suffered more from the Goths, and these other barbarous Nations, than it did from the Saracens, as they are distinguished from the Turks : so in that way of interpretation, there is not that remarkable and palpable gradation to be found, which is implied amongst these woes. Some apply this to Gregorius, because of his prediction foresaid, and the words agree well to his time: but this Angel foretelleth three woes, and he did but foretell one at most. It is like therefore that no person is signified by this Angel in particular; but, the Lord by it giveth John, and by him, others, warning, that there were sadder things coming after the first four had come. Hence,
Observe, 1. The nature of Truth and Error; the one is like light, the other like darkness; the one comfortable and profitable, the other comfortless and hurtful. Obs. 2. The nature of declining among Ministers and Professors in a Church is such, that, when once begun, it groweth. Obs. 3. The nature of judgments, when once inflicted they ordinarily pursue a person or people, and the greatest come last: when people abuse the light, it draweth on the darkening of it by degrees, and it resteth not till it come to a height. Unthankfulness for the Gospel, and not receiving the Truth in love, provoke God to give up to strong delusion, to believe lies, 2 Thes. 2.11, 12. Obs. 4. God's way of dealing with His people, in giving warning before the judgment come, that these three great plagues come not on them unawares; He warneth, that folks may repent, and His own may be armed ere judgment come. 5. The Angel pronounceth a woe thrice, Observe, That spiritual judgments or offenses, have many woes in them; and warnings against them would be doubled, and tripled, and cried with a loud voice: for, when once such judgments cease upon people, they get not easily out from under them, and are not easily affected with them, Therefore is the woe proclaimed thrice and so loud.
LECTURE I.
CHAP. IX.
Vers. 1.
ANd the fifth Angel sounded, and I saw a Star fall from heaven unto the earth: and to him was given the key of the bottomless-pit.
2.
And he opened the bottomless pit, and there arose a smoke out of the pit, as the smoke of a great furnace, and the Sun and the Air were darkened, by reason of the smoke of the pit.
3.
And there came out of the smoke locusts upon the earth, and unto them was given power, as the scorpions of the earth have power:
4.
And it was commanded them that they should not hurt the grass of the earth, neither any green thing, neither any tree, but only those men which have not the seal of God in their foreheads.
5.
And to them it was given that they should not kill them, but that they should be tormented five months: and their torment was as the torment of a scorpion, when he striketh a man.
6.
And in those days shall men seek death, and shall not find it, and shall desire to die, and death shall flee from them.
7.
And the shapes of the locusts were like unto horses, prepared unto battle, and on their heads were as it were crowns like gold, and their faces were as the faces of men.
8.
And they had hair as the hair of women, and their teeth were as the teeth of lions.
9.
And they had breastplates, as it were breastplates of iron, and the sound of their wings was as the sound of chariots of many horses running to battle.
10.
And they had tails like unto scorpions, and there were stings in their tails, and their power was to hurt men five months.
11.
And they had a king over them, which is the angel of the bottomless pit, whose name in the Hebrew tongue is Abaddon, but in the Greek tongue hath his name Apollyon.
T He fifth Angel soundeth here, where the first of the greatest woes is brought in; of what dreadful nature it is, the woes that are prefaced to the sounding of it may declare. It will concern the opening of all, to consider of what woe this judgment speaketh particularly, and to what it relateth. It is more largely described than any of the former, because the temptation of it was most dangerous, and the effects thereof of more concernment to the Church.
1. The object of this judgment, is, the same Church, or Christian world, whereupon the effects of the former trumpets did fall: for, these last three do signify greater degrees of wrath upon these who had despised and abused the former lesser woes.
2. The Christian world is obscured by the trumpets, and the Antichristian brought in its place, as was said at the entry to the trumpets: for, the Antichristian world is in being after the sixth trumpet, when the vials begin; it must therefore have attained that being under the trumpets, and especially under the immediate foregoing trumpets; seeing the seventh fi • death it at its height: and so consequently, the Christian world ( i.e. the pure Church) must be decaying under these trumpets, where the Antichristian cometh to its being (seeing two of these worlds cannot consist together) yea, the Church must be lowest, and decline most under these trumpets, wherein Antichrist groweth most, and cometh to the greatest height, as under these first two great woes it must be. Whence we may gather, 1. That the Church is here the object of this plague. 2. That Antichrist must grow under these trumpets, and particularly under this, it being a further step of the same kind of plague, and the sixth finding Idolatry under Antichrist at a height, which it plagueth, it must then grow here. 3. This first great 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 , bringeth spiritual plagues and tyranny upon this world, by this King and his Armies, who advance that Idolatry. The sixth bringeth temporal judgments on the same persons, for whoring from God, and receiving this idolatrous worship.
For further clearing of this, we say, 1. It is not any temporal judgment by Armies (such as the sixth trumpet holdeth forth, to wit, one of a mixed nature) such as came by the Saracens ; for, that would not be so far greater than the former woes of that kind, as is said. 2. These locusts are but called as horses, or, like horses, verse. 7. not horses themselves, 〈◊〉 is expre • lie said of these under the sixth trumpet, thereby giving us to know that there is something of their nature signified, rather than what is literally expressed. 3. Their power is not to kill, as in the sixth trumpet, but to hurt men and torment them spiritually, and not to kill them bodily, as verse. 3. 4. These are secluded and exempted from this plague, that were sealed and marked, to wit, the Elect, God's servants; but these were not excluded from temporal plagues, (as appeareth, Chap. 11.) nor from that of the Saracens : often they share most under these, and these marked ones are all such as were written in the Lambs Book, Chap. 13.8. who yet did partake deeply of outward afflictions. 5. These troubles ( Chap. 11.) belong expressly to this trumpet, though continuing under • he sixth, and contemporary with it; yet they belong not to it, but to this: for, these troubles are upon the Saints by way of persecution: the sixth hath judgment on ungodly professors by way of justice. 6. All the circumstances will clear this further, as the mean by whom, a Star, his opening the bottomless pit, the darkening of the Sun, &c. as after will appear: for these locusts do darken light, and obscure truth; which showeth it is a spiritual evil on Religious things, springing up from within the Church, which also answereth the scope of these trumpets best, as is said.
2. We say further, the rising and discovering of Antichrist and the fall of the Roman Bishops, from Heaven to Earth (though not at first at their height is the very thing foretold here, and must be so, 1. Because it is clear, that the beasts (mentioned Chap. 13.) are to be understood of him, and speak of the rise of Antichrist particularly, as may then be made out; but this agreeth to that, and is the very same War, and event, though in different expressions: For, 1. The very same persons are overcome by both, to wit, these that are not sealed. 2. The same persons are exempted from both, to wit, these sealed ones, Chap. 9.4. Chap. 13.8. and 14.1, &c. 3. The same mark keepeth both free, the same seal of God. And, 4. The number is the same, comparing Chap. 7. in that number and Chap. 14.2. 2. That the 11. Chapter and these troubles do belong to the Antichrist, it is clear, verse. 7. the witnesses are to be killed by the beast, and what beast but that, Chap. 13. (which ascendeth out of the bottomless pit, as the locusts do here) and that, Chap. 11. belongeth to this trumpet, appeareth from verse. 14. where it is said, the second woe is past, and the third▪ woe cometh quickly. Then all preceeding that, belongeth to the first▪ or the second woe; But not to the second; as hath been said, Therefore to the first, which indeed in this event is contemporary with the second, to wit, the sixth trumpet. It may be also further cleared from the circumstances, considering the time, rise and progress, and by comparing it with the fifth vial, which is poured out ( Chap. 16.) on the beasts seat: and this order is observed in all, what is built of Antichrists Kingdom by the trumpets, is overturned by the vials, and in that same order. It would then appear, that seeing the fifth vial overturneth his throne, that it was settled by the fifth trumpet.
A third reason, is, if that storm against which the one hundred forty and four thousand ( Chap. 7.) are sealed, be the spiritual defection of the Church under Antichrist. Then that which is holden forth by this trumpet is so also; for, both relate to the same storm; but that ( Chap. 7.) is to be understood of Antichrists reign, as the greatest evil the Church was to meet with, after Heathenish persecution, Therefore this must be so also. What was said upon Chap. 7. for clearing the scope of that place, will confirm both these propositions.
4. This spiritual Kingdom, described here, must either be applied to the Kingdom of Antichrist and that Hierarchy, or it must be applicable to some other; (seeing it is some spiritual plague arising within the Church) But there can be no other thought of, to whom this description can agree, and in whom this spiritual woe, (exceedingly beyond any mentioned by the former trumpets) can be fulfilled, but the Kingdom of Antichrist; Therefore that must be understood here.
Again, it being clear, that it is one and the same world or Church which is ovērturned by the first six trumpets, and it being clear, that the sixth trumpet following findeth Idolatry in the visible Church, (which is the world plagued by it) It must therefore follow, that this defection to Idolatry (which is a character of the Antichrists defection) must have increased under this fifth trumpet immediately preceding, seeing it was not during the former four.
Lastly, It may be confirmed further by comparing this Chapter with 2 Thess. 2. by which we will find, that this plague mentioned here, is the same spiritual Antichristian delusion prophesied of there: for in every material thing they agree. As, 1. the instrument, there is one sitting in the Temple of God, as having place in the Church of Christ; here is a Star falling from Heaven, intimating the same thing. 2. There, he is called 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 , as opposit to Christ, and 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 , or the son of perdition; here he is called 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 , or the destroyer, as opposed to Christ, who is called a Savior; as also ( Chap. 17. of this prophesy) he is said to go 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 , or to destruction, himself; for, Antichrist, as Chrysostom observeth in that a Thess. is called the son of perdition, because he shall occasion the destruction of many, and shall himself be destroyed. 3. They agree in respect of these whom they plague: 2 Thess. 2.10. it is also these that shall be damned, whom that delusion carrieth away; here ( verse. 4.) it is only these who are not marked, that is to say ( Chap. 13.8.) who are not written in the Lambs Book of life; and so also it seaseth only finally upon the Reprobate. 4. There, they are given up to strong delusion to believe lies; here, they are carried away with fornications, idolatries and other errors, and are so hardened therein, that although they be plagued for these by the sixth trumpet, yet they repent not. 5. That delusion (2 Thess. 2.) hath its rise from the devil, verse. 9. and is carried on with mighty signs and wonders; here, it cometh from the bottomless pit, and is carried on by the devils special minister, who therefore is said to have the key thereof, and is not without mighty signs and lying wonders, as is clear from Chap. 13. following, where the same Kingdom is under another consideration described. From all which considerations we may gather,
1. That each of these trumpets doth not contain the story of an equal time, or number of years; for, the matter contained in any of the last three trumpets, will be found to be of longer continuance than all the first four, which (added to the greatness of the matter contained in them) may be the reason why they are differenced from the former four, as the greater woes.
2. It appeareth also, that by the fifth and sixth trumpets we are to understand different evils and enemies; and so they cannot both be applicable either to Antichrist only, or Mohammedans only.
3. We may gather also, that this Kingdom and Army, with the furniture wherewith they are provided, and the effects which follow upon their tyranny, are not properly to be understood of external battles and bodily evils, but figuratively, as representing some great spiritual hurt on the Church and her Ordinances. These expressions, they are like horses, and had breast-plates, as it were breast-plates, &c. whereby they are expressly differenced from the trumpet following, wherein expressions that are properly to be understood, are used, and do intimate this.
4. Supposing (which afterward from Chap. 11.13. and 17. will be more clear) that the Roman Hierarchy, complexly taken, is the Kingdom of Antichrist; and that the deluding of the world by them, is the very delusion prophesied of, 2 Thess. 2. It will necessarily follow, that this Romish Antichristian Kingdom (whereby the visible Church hath been long brought in bondage) is the very same set forth by this trumpet.
To come more particularly to the description of this Kingdom (for, a Kingdom it is) as it is set down in the words, in its rise and growth, we will find it many ways insisted upon, 1. A Star falleth from heaven, and becometh earthly; upon that again followeth corruption of Doctrine, whereupon doth arise a rabble of superstitious Church-men, whose work is to propagate and support the dominion of their King, as his care is to strengthen and increase them, there being such mutual concernment in the standing or falling of each to other.
Vers. 1. The first particular described, is, the fountain and great instrument of all this spiritual plague, that is, I saw a Star fall from heaven unto the earth. That by Star is meaned some person, the words after do clear: To him, that is, to the Star was given, &c. That it must be some Church-officer, is also clear from Chap. 1.20. from our Lord Jesus His own exposition: and considering what power this Star hath in the world, it must hold forth some eminent Church-officer. By Heaven, is understood here (as frequently in this Book) the visible Church, which is the Heaven wherein Christ hath placed Apostles, Pastors and Teachers as Stars to give light, because the Church is furnished with heavenly privileges, heavenly light of Doctrine, and ought to be of heavenly conversation in respect of the rest of the world. By Earth is understood earthliness, or the rest of the world, as contradistinguished from the Church, which the opposition cleareth; and thus, Earth signifieth worldly designs, worldly grandeur, corrupt doctrine, liker to that of Heathens than that of Christ, carnalness in conversation, and such like: for, this Earth is something contradistinguished from, and opposed to, the Heaven formerly mentioned. To fall here from heaven unto earth, signifieth a declining from the one to the other. And so in sum, the meaning of this part of the Verse will be, I foresaw the defection of some eminent Church-officer (who once had pláce in the visible Church) from Christian simplicity, purity and holiness in Doctrine and Conversation, to a Religion and way of living by superstitions, Idolatries and external pomp, becoming rather the men of the world, and liker their way than a Minister of Christ.
By this phrase also ( I saw a Star fall, &c. ) is implied, 1. Not only a declining and defection, but such a declining as maketh him that was before a Star in Heaven, to cease from being considered in that relation, and afterward to be accounted as but eminent amongst the men of the world, because of their worldly earthly-like Religion and Worship. Upon which ground, the followers of this Antichristian Kingdom, are called Gentiles, Chap. 11.2. 2. This phrase importeth a visible and palpable step of this defection: the Star is not now falling, as was in the former Chapter; but it is fallen. And I saw it fallen, saith John, implying an observablnesse in it. 3. It importeth, that after the fall of this Star, and defection of this eminent Church-officer, he continued still in the account of a Star among the men of the world: he is called a Star, even after his fall, though indeed, and in John's account he be but a fallen Star and earthly, as having indeed forfeited his former Church-relation.
The second thing described, is, the power given unto this fallen Star, And to him Was given the keys of the bottomless pit. Keys signify in Scripture, Authority and Power. By the bottomless pit, is meaned Hell, as is unquestionable, Chap. 1.18. Christ is said to have the keys of Hell and Death, that doth signify His supreme Authority: Chap. 13.2, 4. the devil is said to have power, and to give it to the beast; because, in God's secret Wisdom and Justice, the execution of His judgments in part is committed to the devil, and he is employed as supreme head of the wicked therein, and for that cause is said to have a throne, and is permitted to rule over the children of disobedience: here, this Star partaketh of this Authority, not as Christ hath it (for now, being fallen from Heaven, he hath lost relation to Him) nor in that same degree as the Devil doth; but as deputy and leiv-tennant to Him, who in God's secret Justice furnisheth him with this power, as from Chap. 13. 2, 4. is clear. In a word, while he was in Heaven he exerced Christ's Authority, and in that respect had the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven. Now, being fallen, he continueth to exercise Authority, and to retain a key, but of a quite contrary nature, to wit, of the bottomless pit, and to serve another master, to wit, the devil, as the exercise of his Authority tending now to the advancement of ignorance, darkness, superstition, and Idolatry in the Church, and being assisted with the power of Hell for that end: for, as Christ's Ministers are said to have keys from Him, and when they warrantably exerce them, it is the opening of Heaven; So promovers of heresy, being Ministers of Satan, 2 Cor. 11. (though they think it not) of whom Antichrist is the chief, he hath the key of the pit, that is, an Authority not allowed by Christ, nor from above: and the opening of the pit with the key, is the putting of that assumed power in execution; such is spreading of corrupt Doctrine, called therefore doctrines of devils, 1 Tim. 4.1. and authorizing men to propagate these without Christ's call, who are therefore called Ministers of Satan. This key is said to be given him : which doth not imply a warrantable call; But, 1. the great change which followed upon his fall, and the exercise of his power in respect of what it was, he getteth now another key in his hand. 2. An usurpation of the person acting, and promoting the designs of Hell, in a way of Authority, as if that key had been entrusted to him. 3. It implieth a prime Ministerial office (to say so) which he hath from the devil, who doth account of, and acknowledge him, as primely subservient to his designs, and a subordination of this key-bearer unto him, who hath given him this trust, Chap. 13.2, 4. Lastly, It implieth a wise and just, though a secret, overruling providence of God, ordering this subordinate Authority of Antichrist for His wise ends, as He doth the dominion of the devil, whom He permitteth sovereignly (as it were) in respect of the other to bear a kind of rule.
Vers. 2. The exercise of this power is set down with three effects following thereupon, verse. 2, 3. And he opened the bottomless pit, that is, as he was employed by the devil, and permitted by God to assume an Authority for the advantage of Hell, so did he instantly exercise his power for that end, and left nothing unassayed for bringing superstition and Idolatry out of the bottomless pit: where it was formerly restrained, now it is letten louse, as appeareth by the effects, The first whereof, is, There arose a smoke out of the pit, as the smoke of a great furnace. What is to be understood by this smoke, the second effect following upon this, to wit, darkening of the Sun and the Air, will make it appear: for, by Sun and Air are understood here, the light and purity of the Doctrine of Christ, which shined clearly and comfortably in the Primitive Church. The third part of this light was smitten by the fourth trumpet, Chap. 8.12. Now, by this fifth trumpet this darkness spreadeth, and the whole Sun and also the Air is darkened, which holdeth forth a greater degree of corruption in Doctrine, than was under the former: it began then, but now is at a height. This being then the meaning of darkening the Sun and Air, this smoke, which bringeth forth this effect, must be these corrupt and superstitious Doctrines, and increasing of human traditions and ceremonies, whereby the light of the Truth of God was obscured. This is compared to a great smoke, 1. Because error and superstition, though it seemeth to be something sib to devotion (as smoke is to fire) yet is really not only without light and heat, but also is onerous and hurtful, as smoke is. 2. Because the darkness which error and superstition inferreth upon the Truth of God, doth not corrupt it in itself, more than smoke can darken the Sun; but doth by ceremonies and traditions darken it to us, as great smoke doth the Sun to onlookers. Again, this smoke is said to be as of a great furnace from the bottomless pit, to show, that the defection of Antichrist consisteth not in one particular error, but (as it were) an inundation of errors ascending together. 2. To show, that whatever the Authors pretended, Yet the rise of these superstitions were from Hell, as in the forecited place, 1 Tim. 4.2, 3. superstitious traditions, and errors concerning Meats and Marriages (Doctrines much esteemed of among Papists) are particularly by the Apostle attributed unto devils.
Vers. 3, The third effect following upon these two, v. 3. And there came out of the smoke locusts upon the earth, a vermin, (as it were,) engendered by the former corruptions; these, as being of special concernment in the Antichristian Kingdom, are largely and particularly described. That these locusts were men; yea, that they were pretended Churchmen, promovers of error and superstition, appeareth from this, that they stand in subordination to Antichrist, and in a Monarchick way are governed by Abaddon, verse. 11. and must therefore be servants suitable to such a master, and members conform to such a head. They are said to come out of the smoke, because oftentimes corruption of Doctrine begetteth corrupt Teachers to promove the same, as we see in Jeroboam, 2 Chron. 11.14, 15. and 2 Tim. 4.3. the rejecting of sound Doctrine and heaping up Teachers after men's own lusts, are put together: for, a spirit of error loveth to innovate in respect of Officers, as well as Doctrine, and by it people are some way disposed to strange Teachers; and also for promoving new tenets, they are necessitated to make use of them. However the scope and sum of the prophesy is thus, that the beginning of Antichrists kingdom shall be by an eminent Church-officer, who, falling from the right exercise of Ministerial Authority in subordination to Christ, to be a promover of the devils designs, and subservient to him, be shall bring in such abundance of ceremonies, superstitions and errors upon the Church which shall obscure the clear Doctrine and simplicity of the Gospel, whereby numbers of false Teachers, and orders shall be established, which our Lord Jesus hath never warranted. They are compared to locusts, 1. Because of their number, as Antichrist shall bring in many errors, so shall he multiply Teachers, who shall live and converse together in the world like swarms of locusts. 2. To set forth their nature, and that both in respect of their worthlessness, and also of their hurtfulness unto the Church, this being the nature of locusts to consume and destroy where they come, so that a land pleasant like Eden before them, is brought by them to a desolate wilderness, Joel 2.3, &c. compared with Chap. 1.4. These orders and teachers shall even do so with the Church: yea, the increasing of them is marked here, as a part of Antichrists superstition, as a fruit of former corrupting of Doctrine, and as a mids to carry on that corruption to a height; by which we may see, that the altering or inventing of new Officers in the Church, is of no little concernment. By these locusts, we conceive clearly to be holden forth the many invented orders and superstitious rabble of these called the Clergy of the Church of Rome, who not being plants of our heavenly Fathers planting, but purposedly brought in to promove and support the worldly grandeur of that Hierarchy, and did flow from superstitious principles brought in upon the Church; and so are to be accounted as locusts, having their rise from the bottomless pit, which their description will more fully clear.
The first part of their description (beside their rise already spoken of) is the power that was given them, which is these four ways set forth, 1. Generally, verse. 3. unto them was given power, as the scorpions of the earth have power, &c. Scorpions are a dangerous and subtle sort of Serpents; these look like locusts, but sting like scorpions, that is, dangerously and subtly, their hurt being beyond their appearance, by their cunning instilling poisonous Doctrine: their having of power given them, doth not import lawful authorizing of them, but, as was said of their head, verse. 1. they want not commission, but that is given them by the Angel of the bottomless pit, who doth formally authorize and create these orders, and prescribeth rules unto them, so that even his Officers and Ministers have order among them, and assume not commission and calling (although to superstitious orders) of themselves. This is fully made out in the Popes way of founding, creating, commissionating, &c. by his bulls, patents and other writs (as they give them names) of all orders, whereof many hundreds are in that Kingdom; all which have their dependence on him, owe their being to his Authority, and are regulated by the Laws and Commissions given them from him.
Vers. 4. The second way how their power is described, it, v. 4. where their Commission is bounded and ordered in these two respects, 1. In respect of these they shall not hurt; it was commanded them that they should not hurt the grass of the earth, &c. whereby is understood (as is clear by the opposition following) the Elect or sealed ones. This command cometh not from their immediate superior, to wit, the Angel of the bottomless pit, but proceedeth from the Lord's Sovereignty, in order to the fulfilling of what was foretold, Chap. 7. Again, the proper objects unto whom their power reacheth, are set down, to wit, but only these men which have not the seal of God in their foreheads, that is, these who are not elected: here the end of Christ's sealing, and the advantage of it doth appear, and also who they are upon whom the delusion of Antichrist hath full victory.
Vers. 5. 3. Their power or Commission is described further in a twofold limitation, v. 5. 1. And it was given to them that they should not kill them, that is, that their plaguing of men should not be directly by taking away the bodily life (as the horse-men under the sixth trumpet have, v. 18.) but must be understood of another sort of plague as afterward. If any say that Antichrist is said to kill, Chap. 11.13.17. and so, how can this be said of him? Answ. We may consider Antichrist in a twofold respect, 1. In respect of the Elect: 2. In respect of hypocritical Professors in the Church. In respect of the first, Antichrist is here limited from killing them spiritually, but in these places he is permitted to kill them bodily. On the contrary again, in respect of the second, Antichrist doth not take away the life bodily of these that submitteth to him, but he proveth a spiritual plague unto them. Now, if we consider him in the first sense, as he corrupteth the Elect, Antichrist is not the plague of the world; but in the second sense, as souls are endangered by him. And therefore this being a threatening of sending him as a plague to the hypocrites of the Church, his proper commission in reference to them is only set down. 2. This limitation may be put in, to show the proper work of these locusts, which should not be professedly to take away bodily lives themselves (from which, as to its act, the Romish Clergy doth superstitiously pretend to abstain, although they be deep in bloody contrivances) but that their native work should be the destroying of souls. The second limitation in this Verse, is in respect of the time; it is not forever, but for five months. We understand it indefinitely for a considerable long time, yet a time that is bounded by the Lord and will have an end, as ( Ezek. 39.12.) seven months are to be taken also. It is probable that particularly five months are mentioned, because ordinarily locusts continued to destroy during five months, as it is written of them; for, beginning in April, they died in September. If we should aim to be more definite in applying this time, it would but prove more troublesome, and uncertain, than satisfying or edifying.
The last thing wherein their power or commission is described, is, in the nature of the plague itself, that is, it was not that they should kill men, but that men should be tormented, &c. This torment in the greatness of it, is aggreged by a similitude in the end of the fifth Verse, their torment was as the torment of a scorpion, which is a grievous, dangerous, and vexing torment.
Vers. 6. The second aggravation, is, v. 6. from the effect of this, Men shall seek death, and shall not find it, and shall desire to die, and death shall flee from them. In sum it is this, their anxiety shall be so great, as shall make them weary of their life (as we see often good men wish for death under great anxiety of spirit, not as death is considered in itself, but as usually it is accounted an end to present vexations, as Job and Jonah ) and yet death shall not prove comfortable to them; but death (that is, a quieting death which they desire) shall flee from them, and thoughts of death shall breed a new terror to them. For understanding this, two things are to be observed, 1. That it is not bodily torment which the Text speaketh of, but Spiritual anxiety and inward vexation of spirit, and that such as natively floweth from the practices and doctrine of these locusts: For, 1. this torment is on the friends and native subjects of this Kingdom, whom these under-officers do not pretend willingly to torment. 2. Their power is not to kill bodily, and therefore not to torment bodily.
The second thing to be observed, is, that nothing doth more natively breed anxiety and spiritual torment than the principles contained in the Popish Doctrine, and propagated by these who are signified by these locusts. And therefore seeing the spreaders of such Doctrines as breed anxiety and vexation of spirit, and can never satisfy nor quiet a conscience, must be understood here, we can more warrantably apply it to none, than to underlings of the Popish Clergy, and other propagaters of that Kingdom: Where these things are clear, 1. That their Doctrine is apt of itself to breed this vexation of spirit, such as the innumerablnesse of their ceremonies, holy days, Doctrine of merit of works, and uncertainty of Grace and Salvation, perfection of holiness, and fulfilling of the Law of God, with the great yoke of will-worship and superstition, which cannot but bring the zealots of these traditions under much bondage. 2. This is clear, that by their principles there is no quieting of a conscience once wakened: What can their pennances, pilgrimages, satisfactions, indulgences, invocation of Saints and Images, and such like, do to the sprinkling of an heart from an evil Conscience? There needeth no more proof of this, than to read the Writings of some of their Casuists, and to consider the many dotations given for soul-masses, after death, because the Conscience could never be quieted here. 3. We will find also both these made good in experience; Histories are full of instances of the heartless and comfortless life, and anxious death of many members of that Body, which God hath blessed to some, for constraining them to flee over these things to the alone Grace of God in Christ Jesus. Yea, 4. doth not their Doctrine pursue men till death, and after death to torment? their peremptory exacting of auricular confession of all sins, and that under the pain of damnation; their founding of the man's confidence upon the Popes pardon, the Priests absolution, his own penance and holiness, or the virtue of some Sacrament (yea sometimes of some idolatrous invention, as the Mass, &c.) according to their principles, conferring grace by the working of the work (as they call it) and such like, cannot furnish the soul with solid confidence. Beside, the fear of Purgatory doth weaken that hope, or expectation of ease, which otherwise men might have from death: in this sense, though they seek death, yet it fleeth from them, and they obtain not their desire by it, and their vexation dieth not.
Vers. 7. Again, in the seventh Verse, he returneth to the particular description of these locusts. 1. In their appearance or shape; like horses, that is, strong, and swift, and stout, as prepared unto battle. So Gregory before spoke of Priests, calling them Sacerdotum exercitus to usher in Antichrist. They are compared to horses prepared unto battle, because of their courage and expeditnesse in undertaking and prosecuting their designs, and because of the success which followed them, who, as a conquering Army do prevail over the world, which is not armed against them. For which causes, these locusts ( Joel 2.) are compared to horses and Armies. 2. They are said to be crowned with Crowns like gold ; to set forth their outward grandeur and seeming stateliness and authority, which is not so indeed, though it appeared to be so; and therefore said not to be gold, but like gold. In a word, they are like Kings in pomp, and Armies in strength: This agreeth well to their Cardinals, Bishops and others of the Clergy of the Church of Rome. 3. They have faces as the faces of men, that is, a pretended affablenesse, and sociableness in their conversations: thereby to insinuate themselves by rational pretexts upon the affections of men, yet being indeed nothing less than they pretended.
4. ( verse. 8.) They are said to have women's hair : which holdeth forth an effeminatnesse, and vain delicatnesse in their disposition and carriage, and a whorish way of decking themselves, and alluring others to their fornication; for which, this Kingdom ( Chap. 17.) is called the great whore. 5. Their teeth were as the teeth of Lions, that is, cruel and ravenous, notwithstanding of the former appearances, devouring the souls of these that are subject to them, the bodies of these that oppose them, and the goods and estates of both, like these, Mat. 23.15. who devour widows houses, and that under pretext of long prayers. The horses mentioned, verse. 17. have Lions heads ; here they have only lions teeth with the faces of men, and hair of women. The reason of the difference is, although both agree in cruelty and destroying; yet the Popish Clergy (signified here) do more subtly and covertly destroy souls. Therefore are they described by Lions teeth only, which are not so obvious to sight. The Turks again (of whom the sixth trumpet speaketh) do more manifestly appear what they are; therefore are described with Lions heads.
Vers. 9. He proceedeth to describe these locusts in their defensive and offensive arms; they are said to have breast-plates, as it were breast-plates of iron, and the sound of their wings was as the sound of chariots of many horses running to battle. The first part showeth their security from all danger, and the advantage they had in their war; there was no hurting of them more than there is of hurting horsemen well armed with armor of iron. The second part of the verse. showeth the horrible noise and terror wherewith they prosecute their designs when they find opposition; so that Armies with horsemen and Chariots, are not more horrible nor violent in their encounters than they are. In the application to the Clergy of the Church of Rome, both these may be made good by the many privileges and immunities which they possess, whereby they are exempted from dependence on all Monarchs but their own; by the dread of Excommunications and thunderings of Church-censure, while they keep the keys of Heaven and Purgatory, they were not only free of fear or hurt from others, but also when they met with opposition from Emperors and Kings, did with such clamour and violence so persecute them, that no Enemy or Army hath been for a long time so terrible as they, making the world astonished with the stupendiousnesse of their pretended power. The effects of this have been often found, as Histories do witness.
The 10. verse. doth continue the description of these locusts in three particulars more. The first, is, they had tails like unto scorpions. Tails, (Isa. 5.19.) do hold forth the flattering and fawning humor of false Teachers, who insinuate themselves by flatteries and lies, as dogs (to whom they are compared) do with their tails. 2. It is said, there were stings in their tails, that is, not only their mouth and head were hurtful, but their tails: that which seemeth most pleasant to others, and is most delighted in, doth often prove most noisome and hurtful to them. Such fair words and pleasant speeches of corrupt men have ever a sting in them, tending to the seduction of the simple, Rom. 16.18. 3. Their continuance is described, their power was to hurt men five months : this was formerly spoken of, verse. 5. and is again repeated here, either because it was mentioned formerly by way of limitation, that they should torment no longer than the time appointed; here it is to show their continuance, which shall be till the appointed time come; or, it is doubled, to confirm the faith of God's overruling providence in timing both the rise, continuance, and close of this dreadful plague. This verse also being particularly compared with verse 19. following, will also clear the plagues threatened by these two trumpets, to be of distinct and different natures.
Lastly, ( Vers. 11.) Their government is described in three, 1. (contrary to that of locusts, Prov. 30.27.) it is monarchick, they have a King over them, that is, although they be many and various and different among themselves, yet are they all subordinate to one supreme head, who exerceth absolute and independent Authority over all the rest, and who liveth in royal state and majesty in the world, having uncontroverted and illimited power within that Kingdom, and hath all others in subordination to him: it is impossible to indigitate any other by this than the Pope. 2. This Monarch is described by his Office, which is to be the Angel of the bottomless pit : which holdeth forth two things, 1. That he is a servant to that Kingdom of darkness, one commissionated and sent in embassage from it, for its behove; and so is not to be understood of the devil himself, who is not properly sent, but sendeth from the pit. 2. It holdeth forth an eminent trusty and singular messenger of that Kingdom, therefore called (by way of eminency) the Angel of the bottomless pit, and therefore cannot be applied to ordinary false Teachers. In a word, he is the same Star that fell from Heaven, verse. 1. and got the key of the bottomless pit, and the same beast (mentioned, Chap. 13.) to whom the Dragon doth especially give his power and commission as his great Deputy and Vicar in the backslidden Church; and therefore he is said (2 Thess. 2.) to come after the working of Satan, &c. 3. This King, is described from his name, which is set down both in Hebrew and Greek, Abaddon, and Apollyon, a name suitable to such a King and Kingdom. His name in both, signifieth a destroyer, or to destroy; partly, because actively he destroyeth; and partly, because he is to be destroyed. It is set down both in Hebrew and Greek, Because, 1. he usurpeth over all the Church, and proveth a destroyer both to Jews and Greeks. 2. Because in due time he is to be destroyed by both, as we will see on Chap. 16. and 19. and also because the Lord would have him known to be so, both by Jews and Greeks, as Pilate caused write the title above Christ in diverse languages. Our blessed Lord Jesus had two names, one, Jesus, in Hebrew, and Christ in Greek; both which hold Him forth to be a Savior. This King will be satisfied with no less honor and extent of government, yet is described by these titles to be of a quite contrary nature. It is not to be thought, that this King should assume such an odious title, or that any such should be attributed to him by his followers, but that indeed he shall be such, as this title describeth, that is, a most horrible waster and destroyer of the Church of Christ.
This, all alongst, is applicable to the papal Kingdom, whereof the Pope is head, unto which shortly we have hinted the application of it, which standeth sure upon the preceeding grounds and suppositions. For further confirming whereof, we shall, 1. in few words resume some general properties of, and considerations concerning, this plague here described. 2. We shall lay down a little view of the public rise, progress, nature, &c. of the papal Kingdom: from which two, we shall leave the application, by way of conclusion, to be gathered.
1. The object of this plague, is, the visible Church, and hypocritical Professors in it, who are not appointed and marked for eternal life. It is the same Christian world, and light of Ordinances, which is darkened and destroyed by it, which was weakened by the former trumpets. 2. The nature of it, is Spiritual, corrupting the Ordinances of Spiritual life, and bringing with it destruction to immortal souls. 3. The extent of it, is universal, over the face of the whole visible Church, the actors in it are Church-men, once by their places having Power and Authority in the Church of Christ. In time it breaketh out in a Spiritual Kingdom and Hierarchy; and upon a pretended Ecclesiastic account, assuming great Power and Authority, it doth breed, and is supported by swarms of Church-officers: the time of its public appearing to be a Kingdom in an established form, will be found to be about the year 600. for, it followeth immediately the fourth trumpet; which continued the story of that time, and doth immediately precede the rise of the Mohammedans, which from the 700. year forward is at an height, and groweth, as the exposition of the following trumpet will clear. This plague carrieth alongst with it much corrupt Doctrine; yea, bringeth again Idolatry into the Christian Church, as we will see in the close of this Chapter, and especially such corrupt Doctrine as overturneth the comfortable and quieting grounds of the Gospel; it bringeth also to the world great store of new created orders for promoving these Doctrines and supporting that Kingdom, who both by covered subtlety and violence carry on their designs, and many such other particulars.
Now for the second thing propounded, if we will take a view of the papal Kingdom, What will we miss? That it is a Kingdom under one absolute Monarch with most illimited power, having dominion over the Church, being begun and carried on by Church-men, having corrupted the Doctrine of the Gospel, and brought Idolatry again into the Church, are all evident. I shall instance but these three particulars, 1. The nature of the Doctrine and errors brought-in by them, which, though exceeding agreeable to nature, yet exceeding opposit to the way of Grace, and therefore cannot but necessarily and natively be destructive to the solid consolation of souls, and beget fearful horror in the hearts and consciences of poor sinners, so that sometimes the greatest promotters of them, have been forced to abandon these principles under challenges: and their greatest disputants are constrained to acknowledge this, we have one instance in Bellar. de justif. lib. 3. cap. 7. who, after his long dispute of indulgences, merit of works, &c. seeketh to sum up in all in three assertions. The first whereof, attributeth merit unto works; the second alloweth men to confide in their own merits; yet as distrusting this foundation so largely contended for, he addeth a third proposition, propter incertitudinem propriae iustitia & periculum inan • gloriae, tutissimum est fiduciam totam in sola Dei misericordia & benig • itate reponere. So that in end for uncertainty of man's proper righteousness and hazard of vain glory he accounteth it most safe to place our whole confidence in the mercy and goodness of God all • nerly, and giveth this reason, if man hath no merit (saith he) he should not confide; if he hath (which yet is uncertain) it is no hurt or loss to flee only to God's mercy. In which one assertion we may see, 1. The uncomfortablnesse of that Doctrine of merit that can never comfort solidly, because, at the best, it is uncertain. 2. We may see the hazard of it to foster pride and vain glory. 3. We may see the disquietness of it, by which sinners can never be secure, till they have fully renounced it. Suarez also doth homologate Bellarmine in this. And yet this Doctrine of merit is a prime fundamental tenent of that Church, but hath often disappointed the defenders of it, when they had most need of comfort, and hath made them prize the Doctrine of Faith in Christ Jesus in their death, who often thought it absurd in their life: as particularly is written of Charles the fifth, after his laying by of public things in the world and his retiring of himself to a Monastery.
The second instance, is in the abundance and variety of their Religious orders, as they are called, (which take up a main part of the description of this Kingdom) there is at least thirty five orders reckoned, each whereof, for the most part, will comprehend many thousands, beside their Bishops and other members of their Hierarchy. The number of the Monasteries belonging to these orders, are reckoned by some to be 2 • 5044. as is observed by Alstedius in his Chronology: all which have their original by the Popes Authority, hold their dependency on him alone, and are vigorous instruments, specially devoted to the upholding and promoving of his designs.
Lastly, A more particular considering of its rise and public appearance; which was about the same time, to wit, Anno 60 • . and its growth and manner of proceeding afterward will make out this, which was shortly thus,
After the three hundred year, when the Church possessed peace, pride soon infected her Officers, whereby there was ambitious desires after preeminence amongst these who should have been most free of that vice: Rome had many advantages for this end, and her Bishops improved them well, as hath been hinted in the exposition of the former trumpets; yet did never one of them usurp a settled superiority, or the title of Universal Bishop or headship over the Church, till Boniface the third assumed it, about the year 606. Which was upon this occasion: after the seat of the Empire was translated from Rome to Constantinople by Constantine, that Bishop was privileged with all the privileges which Rome enjoyed, by her being formerly the seat of the Emperors court, even as that city was named New Rome, and made fellow in all privileges unto Old Rome : from this, many contentions followed, as is before hinted. While the Emperors court constantly continued there, the Bishops of Constantinople would not be content with equality, but assumed a superiority, and a title suitable to it, of Universal Bishop. This, John B. of Constantinople did a little before the year 600. while Maurice possessed the Empire, who did countenance him, it is like out of respect to the place, where his court resided. This usurpation was generally ill taken, and written against, especially by Gregory Bishop of Rome, who did presage the revealing of Antichrist not to be far off, when men durst be so impudent to take that style, which no Apostle ever usurped. Upon some occasion, the Emperors Army mutinying, did choose one Phocas (a base, vile wretch) Emperor, who having killed all Maurice children before him, did afterward kill himself. Unto this Phocas did Gregory of Rome make addresses, by Commissioners and Epistles, grossly flattering him, and abusing that place of Daniel 4. of God's changing and transferring of Empires, as he had done that for the good of His Church, in removing a tyrant and setting up such a Religious Prince as Phocas was, as may be seen in his Epistles, Lib. 11. Epist. 36, 44, and 43. By this means, Phocas came to favor the Bishops of Rome, and what out of envy towards Maurice name, and what to ingratiate himself in the west by the Bishop of Rome's means. Some few years after (while Boniface, who was at first Gregory's Commissioner to Phocas, possessed the Sea) he passed an Edict, willing and declaring Rome to be acknowledged for the supreme Sea, and the Bishop thereof for supreme and Universal Bishop from that time forth. This decree Boniface the third, within short time caused ratify and pronounce in a Lateran Council of 62. or 72. Bishops; and although it wanted not much contradiction then, and was never fully acknowledged by all the East Churches, yet from that time did this great Roman Hierarchy receive its public rise, and that mystery which long had been working, was obstetricated and brought forth by such a midwife, as this infamous Phocas, Anno 606. as is said. At this time and after (as Platina in vita Bonifacii tertii saith) this Pope and others did put in their decrees, Sic volumus & jubemus ; and saith, that the reason of preferring Rome, was, because the Emperor was still styled Romanorum Imperator, wheresoever he resided.
Immediately after this, the light of the Word wonderfully decayed, traditions were obtruded, all public worship was to be performed in Latin, the Scriptures were keeped up from laick people (as they called them) Litanies, Liturgies, and Masses were brought instead of the Word and preaching. And in effect, all reformations consisted in building Churches and Monasteries, and enriching them with great dotations; plurality of Mediaators and worshipping of Saints and Angels were brought in (especially this was in Vitellianus his time, about the year 666.) Heathenish superstitions and ceremonies were brought again into the Church, the Temple called Pantheon (formerly dedicated to all the heathen gods) was now opened and dedicated to all Saints (this was in Phocas and Innocentius their time; Images were set up in the Church, and appointed to be worshipped: which occasioned great confusion in the Church, and although it was long resisted by the Emperors of the East, and by several Councils both in the East and West, yet was it afterward established by the second Council of Nice. This second Council of Nice was held, Anno 781. or 788. Thi • worshipping of Images was mightily opposed by Leo Isaurus, Constant. Compron. and other Emperors of the East, who for that were Excommunicated by the Popes. At last Irene, a superstitious cruel woman, obtaining the Government after her Husbands death, the foresaid Council of Nice did conclude this Image-worship. It sat first down at Constantinople, but the people being enraged at this their design, they were forced to remove it to Nice. It is marked, Cent. Magd. out of old Writers, that these Emperors urged the removing of Images, that that scandal might not lie before the Saracens, that Christians worshipped Idols; this Council of Nice was also withstood by Charles the great and Ludovicus Pius.
At this time also the Pope grew exceedingly to an height, not only of censuring Bishops and disposing of Bishoprics, but also deposing Kings and disposing of their Kingdoms at his pleasure, supremely and sovereignly to decide all questions whatsoever, and that without all possibility of erring. In a word, in everything so absolute, as he might lead millions of souls to hell, and none might say to him, what doest thou? and all this with wonderful violence and terror to any who should in the least contrary the same: which things are not only practiced by the Head of this Antichristian Kingdom, but also are owned and maintained by these his forementioned Armies to be due to him (as from many particular instances, and their general principles might be made out) all which being put together (especially by the intelligent who are acquainted with their practices and Writings) it may be confidently concluded (which was asserted in the introduction to this Chapter) that the Popish Kingdom is the very Kingdom, the Pope the very King and the Angel of the bottomless pit, the Popish Clergy the very Locusts and Armies, and their Doctrine the very noisome smoke of the pit, which are here somewhat darkly, but exceeding fully and appositly described.
We shall say no more for use of all, But, 1. That we would bless God, who hath so clearly discovered to us this abomination that maketh desolate. And 2. We would bless Him further, that He hath freed us from this tyranny under which a great part of the Christian world doth lie, and by which our own Predecessors were sometimes keeped in bondage. 3. It would provoke us to improve the light and liberty of Truth which He hath conceded to us, and to welcome the soul-comforting Doctrines of the free grace of the Gospel. O what great odds is there betwixt the dispensations of the Gospel which we enjoy, and that which our Fathers lived under! and therefore how much more is required of us? and how much greater will the condemnation of these be, who shall ungratfully perish under this light? Lastly, let it stir us up with holy indignation against this contagion of Popery: ought we to think this a light and indifferent matter, which the Lord hath threatened as so great a woe to the visible Church, and which he doth so significantly delineat in the hellish nature and hurtful effects of it? and let us commiserate the deplorable condition of many thousands of poor souls, captivated under this tyranny, and stung with the poison of these scorpions, who yet cry not when they are bound. And let us cry mightily to God to break this Covenant with death, and to bring this agreement with hell to an end, that the oppressed captives may be let go free, and the Temple may be opened in heaven, and that He may take to Him His great power, and reign, that the Kingdoms of the earth may become the Kingdoms of the Lord, and of His Christ: even so. Amen.
Concerning the comfortless grounds that Popery layeth down for the comforting of poor afflicted Consciences.
IF we might take a view of such grounds as Popery layeth down for the quieting of an exercised Conscience, what a labyrinth would it be found? For, 1. They deny all not imputation of sin or imputation of righteousness, and place remission of sins only in the infusing of a gracious quality in the soul, which they call gratia gratum faciens ; so that if the sin be mortal, this is lost (although the person were formerly just) and must again be recovered. If it be venial, he must satisfy for it. 2. To this kind of remission, they require attrition and contrition. The first is a legal sorrow for fear of wrath, the second is an intense sorrow for the sin committed; the first proceedeth from servile fear, this from filial: both these they lay down as necessary for attaining of the former remission, or infusion of Grace. 3. To this contrition they give a fourfold influence in the attaining thereof, 1. Dispositively, or a disposing influence, as the material cause (as they call it) of this grace, that is, by this contrition as it is a virtue, the soul is disposed for receiving of that grace; or, that that grace may be wrought in the soul, out of that contrition, as the pre-existent matter thereof. 2. If concurreth instrumentally, as it is a part of the Sacrament of Penance, by which, the Priests absolution doth ex opere operato beget such grace in the heart of one that is contrite. These two are laid down by Thom. supplement. Quest. 5. Art. 1. corp. 3. It concurreth by way of satisfaction for the sin committed, and so this inward contrition, in the sensitive part, is man's recompensing for his fault inwardly, as he doth outwardly inflict punishment on the body; ad recompensandam offensam quae in Deum committitur, as Aquinas speaketh, Quaest. 1. Art. 2. 4. It concurreth meritoriously as an act of virtue, even as other works do for procuring meritoriously something from God, supp. Quaest. 1. Art. 2. even the first entrance into glory.
All which ways will be unsatisfying to a conscience; for neither of them looketh on Repentance as that which the Lord of His grace hath promised and knit pardon freely unto: therefore, that it may be meritorious, there ariseth a new dispute; wherein this contrition consisteth. 1. Some old Schoolmen say it must be in summa gradu, otherwise pardon is not to be expected. 2. Others, of whom Scotus is the head, say that it is such a sorrow as is only known to God, and so by it the conscience can have no quiet. 3. The later Jesuits, as Bellar. do p •• niten. lib. 2. cap. 11. and Gregor. de Valent. tom. 4. disp. 7. Quaest. 8. de contritione, do reject both these as false and dangerous: and because that contrition in such a degree is most rare, therefore they have a twofold cure, le • t there be no ground to quiet one at all. 1. Bellarmine distinguisheth contrition in that which is intensive summa and appretiative summa, and saith, that though the first be not, the second will be sufficient, providing the sinner be still pursuing after the first to the uttermost, so that if anything be left undone which might be done for attaining thereof, this ground will fail; and the conscience can have no peace in this, because in it there is a new sin, and what shall satisfy for that? This is also rare, and considering that a wakened conscience will no • easily acquiesce in its own appretiative contrition, as being equivalent for satisfaction, that being only such as desireth to be intensively in the highest degree, as they expound it. Therefore, 2. the weight is laid on the power of the keys, and the Priests absolution in the Sacrament of Penance (which Greg. de Vall • ntiâ • aith is communis Scholasticorum sententia ) that is, that though contrition of itself be not sufficient, yet by virtue of the foresaid absolution, one that is attritus, doth become contritus, and so have the forementioned remission of sins bestowed on him. Therefore they make Baptism simply necessary to the pardon of Original sin, and penance to actual, except when it is impossible; and in this case the vow thereof doth supply. To this sacramental absolution they require particular confession of mortal sins, d • necessitate • almis, to be made necessarily to the Priest, before he absolve them, which can be no little torture; and so still this leaveth the soul to dispute the Priests Commission, and the nature of that Sacrament, which will not easily quiet it, and also leaveth it under Aquinas his unanswerable Argument, suppl. Quaest. 1. Art. 3. Where (saith he) the principles are diverse, the one can never pass unto, or become the other; But the principles of attrition, to wit, servile fear, and of contrition, to wit, filial fear, are diverse. Ergo, &c. When this is done, there is still a stick (even by their principles) in the uncertainty of this, whether their contrition be true or not, or whether that remission hath followed freely or not; for, this, they say, cannot be known but by particular revelation) Therefore do they conclude, that to supply all, it is necessary to enjoin satisfaction in work, by pennances, peregrinations, dotations or such like, whereby they make up equipollently the defects of their contrition, and make all sure: and if the person cannot satisfy himself, because his sins are great, here they have their indulgences, and the application of the satisfactions of others for quieting the mind, whereby the Pope, out of his Treasury and plenitude of Authority, doth apply the satisfaction of some others, who did satisfy and pay more than their own guilt did amount unto, as Bellar. speaketh de indul. lib. 1. cap. 4. The conscience is recommended to this for quietness; whence it is, that so much money is given for these indulgences. These ways indeed oppress the persons and empty the purses of their patients, but can produce no solid cure. This great difficulty followeth ever that way, when external bodily pennances do not the turn, then so many years have they to endure in Purgatory notwithstanding of ordinary indulgences, and this, (as Bellar. saith, lib. 1. de Indulg. cap. 9. pag. 1174) may amount to 20000. years: which is the great courtesy allowed by this way unto a tortured conscience.
The question is, what may become of that person at the day of Judgment when his years will not be expired? By the intensenesse (saith he) of the degree that is to be made up in three or four hundred year. This is the path way of their casual divinity: and after all, they leave the patient at an uncertainty, when they have bestowed all on them, and endured that twenty thousand years in Purgatory, if for all that they may be afterward relieved and brought through; So it is still at a venture, and what peace can be here in this way, where necessarily these four are controvertible? 1. Whether these means, being applied, can work the effect, when no such way is holden forth in Scripture, and is but grounded in many steps on traditions and canons, and disputable principles at the best. 2. Whether a proportionablness can be between its satisfactions or sorrow, and the sin committed, so as they may quiet the conscience, as having appeased God by them, seeing His Justice is infinite, and the deserving of sin is great. 3. Whether its sorrow can be without sin in its self, and so being defective cannot be satisfactory, but must need a satisfaction. 4. Whether its own act of sorrow be sincere or gracious, that is still uncertain, and so cannot but mar peace still as they acknowledge. And to close, it must be a poor peace which is sought-for in Purgatory, by so many years continuance there, and yet not to be sure of it when these shall end. There is nothing liker the anxiety mentioned here than this, which is but an hint of that which is followed in many inextricable disputes concerning these three parts of Repentance, to wit, contritio cordis, confessio oris, and satisfactio operis, which would sooner distract a wearied sinner than give quietness unto him.
LECTURE II.
Vers. 12.
One woe is past; and behold there come two woes more hereafter.
13.
And the sixth Angel sounded, and I heard a voice from the four horns of the golden altar, which is before God,
14.
Saying to the sixth Angel which had the trumpet, Loose the four Angels which are bound in the great river Euphrates.
15.
And the four Angels were loosed, which were prepared for an hour, and a day, and a month, and a year, for to slay the third part of men.
16.
And the number of the army of the horsemen were two hundred thousand thousand: and I heard the number of them.
17.
And thus I saw the horses in the vision, and them that sat on them, having breastplates of fire, and of ja • inct, and brimstone, and the heads of the horses were as the heads of lions, and out of their mouths issued fire, and smoke, and brimstone.
18.
By these three was the third part of men killed by the fire, and by the smoke, and by the brimstone, which issued out of their mouths.
19.
For their power is in their mouth, and in their tails: for their tails were like unto serpents, and had heads, and with them they do hurt.
20.
And the rest of the men which were n • t killed by these plagues, yet repented not of the works of their hands, that they should not worship devils, and idols of gold and silver, and brass, and stone, and of wood: which neither can see, nor hear, nor walk:
21.
Neither repented they of their murders, nor of their sorceries, nor of their fornication, nor of their thefts.
IN the last trumpet were described the nature and success of the kingdom of Antichrist, who was there called, the Angel of the bottomless pit, in opposition to Jesus Christ, who is called the Angel of the Covenant. The visible Church was pestered with corruptions, superstitions and idolatry by him, for which the Lord threateneth to plague them with a more sensible plague by this sixth trumpet.
The 12. Verse, One woe is past, &c. is set down to rid marches betwixt the two trumpets, and to make the transition clear from the one to the other. It is not to be understood, as if the event of the fifth trumpet were fully to precede the sixth, and no ways to contemporate with it (the contrary of this is clear from the close of this Chapter, where the idolatry, brought into the world by the fifth trumpet, continueth unrepented-of during the sixth; but this is to be understood, either as holding forth the priority of their beginning, the fifth preceedeth the sixth, as being the procuring cause of it; or, it relateth only to the former description, and signifieth this much, the description of the first woe is past, and now cometh the typical description of the second. Therefore what we prefaced in general, concerning the order both of seals and trumpets, is to be applied here.
The judgment prophesied of here, at the first reading is exceeding terrible, and so described as must be necessarily understood of some more than an ordinary woe. In this description we have, 1. the rise of this plague, in the supreme and subordinate overrulers thereof, verse. 13, 14—2. The actors and executioners thereof are generally hinted at, v. —14. 3. Their commission is expressed, verse. 15. 4. The executioners and their execution following thereupon are described, verse. 16, 17, 18, 19. 5. The procuring cause of this plague is implied, verse. 20. As also, 6. the end which the judgment aimed at in itself, with the success, (or rather unsuccessefulnesse) which it had, are set down, v. 20, 21.
For the more clear opening of the words, we would premit these generals, 1. The object of this plague, is generally the same with the former, to wit, the visible Church, now drawn to superstition and idolatry by Antichrist, are plagued by this: for, judgments are spoken of in this Book, not as they are indifferently upon the world, but as particularly they concern the Church. And one of these trumpets after another doth contain a further step of judgment upon the self same object; and the Church being the object of the former trumpets, so must she be of this, otherwise the pronouncing of this woe would have with it no further addition to her plagued condition, which is contrary to the scope.
2. The Church here, is to be considered as declined, and as being guilty of Idolatry, and many other gross sins, as is clear by verse. 20.21.
3. It is clear also, that this judgment is of a different nature from the former (as was hinted in the exposition of it) and doth particularly denounce temporal judgment upon the Church, already drunken with Spiritual plagues: this the particular description will demonstrate; yet it is such a judgment in temporal things, as carrieth gross abominations, and Spiritual venom, for poisoning souls, alongst with it; so their having of tails like unto Serpents, &c. doth import.
Lastly, It must also be such a plague as is executed by some great power in the world, who have mighty Armies in executing this in a warlike, violent and successful; though in a barbarous and cruel, manner.
And therefore, in short, we conceive no other to be intended here, but the dominion of the Turks, who, by their mighty strength, great cruelty and poisonous Doctrine of Mahomet, have proven exceeding destructive both to the bodies and souls of innumerable poor Christians: which we may clear a little more in the application, and as we go through the words.
Vers. 13. The first thing John mentioneth, is, a voice, I heard a voice from the four horns of the Golden altar, &c. which setteth forth the voice of God. or of Jesus Christ, as supreme overruler of this plague, with allusion to God's giving answers in His Temple under the Old Testament. This voice giveth orders to the sixth Angel, the subordinate overseer of this plague, to loose, &c. by which is holden forth God's sovereignty over, and His making use of Angels in the ordering of, the most fearful plagues that come upon the Church.
Secondly, The actors are touched at in this order which the Angel getteth, verse. 14. Loose the four Angels, which are bound in the great river Euphrates. Where we have these particulars, 1. Their nature, they are Angels, not properly to be understood; for, the thing which followeth is Armies of horsemen: but they are here called Angels, to signify their being subservient to God in His design, and their being fitted with agility, promptitude, &c. for this work, which He was to employ them in (it being ordinary in all this prophesy to compare instruments good or bad to Angels and Spirits, as, Chap. 9. verse. 11. Chap. 12. verse. 7. and 16. verse. 13, &c. 2. They are called four, not precisly to determine a number; But either, 1. to signify the spreading of this plague to all the corners of the earth, That as ( Chap. 7.1.) there were four Angels holding the four winds, that they should not blow; so there are here as many instruments to hurt the Church, as were there to prevent it. Or, 2. it may be to point out a fourfold difference either in respect of government, place, nature or ceremonies, which should be amongst these who should be actors in this plague, which we will find agreeable to the Turks in this sense also. 3. These four Angels are said to be at the great river Euphrates. This river in Syria, is famous in many respects, 1. Upon it the great city Babylon stood. 2. It was the march of David and Solomon's Kingdom that was from the sea to the river. 3. It was the great fatal bound of the Roman Empire, beyond which they could never extend their dominion. 4. Because of the footing that the Turkish dominion took first beside it; for, the first Turkish government being by four Souldans, all of them for a considerable time had their residence near and about this river, to wit, in Asia, Aleppo, Damascus, and Antioch, which were the places whereby these governors were designed. We conceive this river to be here mentioned, to show, that such should be instrumental in this plague, as were neither within the Church, nor the Roman Empire, but should have their residence beside this river Euphrates, as the Turks are observed to have had before their dominion spread. 4. They are said to be bound in that river, that is, restrained from breaking in upon the Empire, or the Church in it, for a long time, by God's providence, so as if they had been indeed bound for many years, what from intestine divisions among themselves, what by Tamerland's invasion of them, and what by our Lord's providing some instrument to defend His Church for a time: these Turks were restrained from invading and overruning the Empire, although they vehemently gaped after it. They are said to be loosed from that place, when the impediments and restraints, formerly keeping them in, are removed, and they (as it were) hounded like dogs, formerly tied up, to destroy the west part of the Christian world, which accordingly came to pass very speedily, when the Turks (having prevailed over the Saracens ) did with them combine in one dominion under the Ottomanean family; which was about the 1000 year and some more, from which time their power grew till a great part of Europe was overrun by them.
Thirdly, We have their commission, verse. 15. which showeth the end wherefore they were loosed. 1. Their work, is, to slay. 2. The number, is, a third part of men. 3. The time or continuance of their execution, is, for an hour and a day, &c. To slay, is to be here understood properly to take away men's bodily lives: and therefore the expressions in this trumpet differ from what is in the former. The event also here marked, ( the third part was killed, verse. 18.) doth confirm it. Again, by the third part of men is not to be understood any number definitely, nor any indefinite number of the world absolutely considered; but a third part, or, a considerable number of the men living on this side the river Euphrates, from which formerly these executioners were restrained; now, being loosed, they are commissionated especially in respect of them, to wit, the ancient Roman Empire, now become Antichristian. 3. The time, or continuance, is set down in four several words, an hour, a day, a month, and a year. We conceive it not safe to apply it to a day, or an hour of any definite time; (which we would rather reverence than follow in the practice of others) But we understand here a definite time bounded and limited of God for the prevailing of this plague, as there was set down a time to the locusts under the former trumpet. We conceive the words are multiplied, hour, day, and month, and year, to set out, 1. God's particular determining and bounding of that plague in its continuance, to an year, month, day and hour, according to the phrase, Numb. 9.22. whether it was two days, or a month, or a year, &c. which is there used to show the absolute dependence the Israelites had upon God in their marchings and sojournings, whether for time long or short: so shall it be here, the time for which they are prepared, is particularly appointed. 2. They are said to be prepared for such a time, differently expressed, to show, that in diverse respects their continuance should be both for a short time, as of an hour or day; and also of a long time, as of a month and year. 3. To show their alacrity to use the opportunity and liberty given them carefully; so that after the removing of restraints, they should not miss one hour or day in executing their commission, and should prosecute it vigorously, till the year or longest period of their continuance should be finished. Thus may they be said to be prepared, &c.
Fourthly, We come to the executioners themselves, and the execution which followed. They are described more particularly, 1. From their number and nature, verse. 16. The army, is, of horsemen ; and the number, is, two hundred thousand thousand. That which is added, and I heard the number of them, is to show, that John invented not this number, but that he had it plainly revealed to him. They are called horsemen, partly, to show the swiftness and celerity of their success; partly, to show they were such a people as abounded with such warriors. The number we conceive (more than the time) is not definitely to be stuck to; but signifieth an exceeding great number. Both these agree well to the Turks, who have led the greatest Armies in Europe especially of horsemen, and made the swiftest progress after their invasion, which hath been of a long time heard of, much more numerous than ever the Christians were able to oppose unto them.
The riders with their defensive armor, and the nature of the horses (and, it is like, their offensive arms) are described, verse. 17. They had breast-plates of fire and of jacinct and brimstone. Breastplates use not to be made of such matter. We conceive the meaning is, they shall be terrible, dreadful and destructive, as fire, brimstone, &c. which, working terror on these whom they invade, shall occasion such security to themselves from the hurt of any, as if they were fully armed, and also richly, which we conceive to be understood by jacinct. Their offensive arms, or, their offending power, are set out by two expressions. 1. The heads of the horses were as the heads of lions, that is, bold, fierce and destroying, and that professedly without any color or pretext, such as the locusts had. 2. Out of their mouths is said to issue fire and brimstone : whereby it would seem, their wasting and cruel way of proceeding is set forth. Some also think it doth relate to the use of Cannon, Musket and Pistol: For, these two are certain. 1 That the use of these weapons was found out, much about this time. 2. There was never such abundance of them, and of such huge greatness, as was used by them in their European expeditions.
In the 18. Verse, The event of the execution is marked to be answerable to their Commission; By these three was the third part of men killed : this is to be understood properly, as verse. 15. It is marked, to show, that there is no threatening or prediction of God's, but it is exactly fulfilled, and no Commission of His, but it is fully executed. In the application of this, the speedy, terrible and great overthrow of Asia the less, the coast of Africa, and a great part of Europe, being destroyed and overrun by the Turks, are sufficient evidences of the truth of this. Beside the cruel murder committed by the Saracens in Italy, France, Spain, where yet it pleased the Lord to keep them from settling.
Vers. 19. Their manner of hurting is more particularly explained, 1. by a double mean whereby they hurt; Their power is in their mouth and in their tails. By mouth is understood their open violence against the body. The tail signifieth the abominableness of the Doctrine spread by them, which is destructive to souls. 2. These tails are further described, (because their Doctrine was not spoken of before, though their violence had been described) they are said to be like serpents for poisonablnesse and subtlety; and they have heads, an unnatural-like thing that tails should have heads on them. This setteth out the gross abominablnesse and absurdity of that Doctrine. The locusts had tails, but they had not heads on them; these have heads, to show, that it shall be more discernible in its grossness than the former. It is added, and with them they do hurt, that is, with their tails and heads. The first part of the Verse showeth, that this Army hurteth both by cruelty to the body, and pestiferous Doctrine to the soul: therefore it is said, their power is in their mouth and their tails. This last part showeth the success that followed upon their Doctrine; there were many souls hurt and destroyed with this, as there were bodies with the former. This fully agreeth to the Turks also, who are not more terrible in their Armies to the bodies of men, than that pestiferous delusion of Mahomet is of itself hurtful and destructive to souls, and actually hath destroyed many, a great part of the world in God's righteous judgment being carried away with it.
We come now to the 20. and 21. verse. And the rest of the men which were not killed by these plagues, yet repented not, &c. The scope whereof, is, 1. To show what sins procured so great a plague, and so fierce an enemy to be letten loose upon the Christian world; and indeed the consideration of these sins will vindicate the justice of God in inflicting all these evils. There is one sin mentioned in this verse, to wit, idolatry, several ways aggreged; and there are four moe in the last verse added: and though God will suffer cruel abominations in Pagans, that never had the knowledge of His will; yet these who are guilty here, being by profession of His Church, there is the greater access in justice to take course with them. 2. It is set down to show the end which the Lord drove by such strong Physic; it was at the health, and not the subversion of that part of the world; and so by the application of this mean, either to bring them to repentance, as the right fruit of all, or to discover their desperate impenitency. 3. It showeth the fruitlesnesse of this mean, that notwithstanding it was sharp, yet did it not prevail with them; which is not to be understood, as if God failed of His intended purpose, but to show how mad the Antichristian world was upon their Idols, when such a judgment, having destroyed so many, did not yet effectuate the recovery of the rest.
By the rest of the men which were not killed, &c. is to be understood, not these who remained all the world over, but within the Christian World or Empire now declined to be Antichristian. The rest that remained, after the third part were killed of the same total, to wit, these on this side Euphrates ; for, the Lord observeth not what the rest of the world did, but what His Church by profession did, whom He correcteth when He forbeareth all the world beside.
What we said in preface to the trumpets, in general, and to this, doth also confirm it. They are said not to repent, that is, that these idolatrous Christians, notwithstanding of these plagues, neither were inwardly brought to loath these sins, or to be humbled for them before God; nor outwardly to abstain from them in their practice, but rather grew worse and dotted more upon these superstitions, even after this plague, which fully came to pass also, Papists being never more drunk with their superstitions, and profane in their carriages, than since the Turks destroyed a great part of that Antichristian Kingdom.
The first sin mentioned, is, Idolatry, four ways aggreged, 1. The works of their hands : so called, because the Images and statutes used in that worship, are made with men's hands, and so cannot be a fit object of worship. It is like hereby to relate to the second Command, where the making of all such, upon such an account, is forbidden. 2. It is called a worshipping of devils, not that it is so directly in the intention of the worshippers, but that it is so indeed, and accounted so by the Lord. Therefore it is usual in the Scripture to give it that name, Levite. 17.7. 1 Cor. 10.20. Yea, not only that sort of Idolatry, which is against the first Command, is so called; but even that which acknowledging the true God, doth yet corrupt the rule of Worship prescribed by Him, by putting an Idolatrous manner in the room thereof. So, that Idolatry of Jeroboam the son of Nebat is styled, 2 Chron. 11.15. he ordained him Priests for the high places, and for the devils, and for the calves which he had made : and yet the particular considering of that sin, will make it appear, that he did not directly intend the worshipping of these calves (and much less of devils) in the room of God. 3. This Idolatry is aggreged from the variety and multiplicity of it, in respect of the matter whereof these Idols were compounded, gold, silver, brass, stone and wood, (of which metals of all sorts, Images, Crucifixes, Relicts, &c. are abundant in the Popish Church) and yet whatever be the shape of the metals, it is still, at the best, gold, silver, brass, &c. and so no fit object of worship. Lastly, It is aggreged from the lifelesnesse of these Idols, which being unable to hear, or move themselves, must be exceeding unfit to be invocated by others, as helpers of them; and so must imply exceeding great stupidity in these who fell into that sin. Upon which ground, the Scripture usually aggregeth that sin, Psal. 115. verse. 4.5, &c. and 135.15, 16. both which places do pronounce the worshippers of them to be for stupidity like unto them.
There are four moe particular sins charged upon them, verse. 21. and impenitency under the same also. All which may be figuratively understood according to the strain of this Book, or properly, as the words sound. The first sin, is, their murders ; figuratively understood, it holdeth forth the great blood-guiltiness of souls, which we formerly hinted at in the exposition of the fifth trumpet. Properly, it holdeth forth the many massacres, persecutions and butcheries of Antichrist, whereby that Kingdom is guilty of the blood of many thousands of the Saints, as from Chap. 11.7. and 13.7. and 18.24. will appear. The second thing, is, their sorceries, which figuratively holdeth forth bewitching and intoxicating Doctrine, and delusion therein, at a height: literally taken, it holdeth forth a guiltiness of devilish and magical arts. According to the first sense, the whore is said to have a cup, Chap. 17.4. according to the last, Antichrist is said to come (2 Thess. 29.) after the working of Satan, with signs and lying wonders. The thing signified by both, will be found in Popery, their Doctrine having bewitched and blinded so many, and Magic vented in lying signs and wonders, and other abominable pranks, hath been abounding and frequent not only amongst the inferior Clergy, but even in the Popes themselves. And this, under the pretext of working miracles and exorcisms, hath been in some cases • vouched. The third sin, is, fornication : by which we may understand their whorish Doctrine, which draweth souls away from God, in which respect that Kingdom is called the great whore; or, bodily filthiness (which we will often find in Scripture to go alongst with idolatry, as from the counsel of Balaam, ( Numb. 3 • .16 and elsewhere) may appear. This sin is not wanting in the Popish Church, especially in the Clergy, their pretended vows are snares to bring it on, as experience hath proven; yea, Bellarm. de Monachis lib. 2. cap. 24. saith, that it is more tolerable to commit fornication, than for one under a vow to M • rrie, although he have not the gift of continence, because, saith he, Marriage reddit eu •• inh • bilem ad votum servandum, which the other doth not. By their principles they maintain Bordels. It is said in Rome alone, the permission of them have yielded yearly 40000 Crowns to the Pope. This sin is especially eminent among their Clergy, and often in their Head the Pope himself: yea, one Pope Iean, or John according to others, is recorded to have brought forth a child in her Popedom. These things are not forged, but partly from experience have been found, and by their own Historiographers have been set down; partly, by some Godly men in these times, and others more civil have been often complained on and regrated; partly, are manifest from the Popes donations, and offices fr • quently bestowed upon their children, which continue to this day as avowed testimonies of their public accession to this sin. The last, is, their thefts, that is, the breach of the eighth Command, taking and wronging the estates of men, and by indirect means drawing them to themselves, without any warrantable right. This is especially applicable to the Romish Clergy, who by the pretext of dotations, mortifications, indulgences, annates, Peters patrimony and Peters -pence, and such like means, have engrossed to themselves the whole substance almost of Christendom. This sort of theft in the Pharisees, was long since condemned by our Lord as a breach of the Commandment of God, Matth. 15.5. and 23.14. with 25. Of all which sins, it is not only implied that the Antichristian world is guilty; but also that they, that is, the two parts not destroyed by the Turks, continue so to practice without repenting of the same.
The charging of the Popes with these foul faults, will not seem strange, if we consider what Platina, Martinus Onuphrius their own writers, and Bellarmine, himself writeth concerning them from the 670. forward: where abounded, 1. Irregularity in elections by bribes, magic arts, ambition, faction and violence, by poisoning and incarcerating their predecessors: so that Platina, in vita Stephani 6. saith, • o deventum erat Ecclesiasticis, ut largitionibus sedem obtinerent ; The Church-men came to this condition that they got the Papacie by bribes. And Damas. 2. vi sedem occupavit, inoleverat enim hic mos, ut cui seditioso liceret Petri sedem invadore ; he took the Papacie by force, for this was the custom, that any seditious person might by violence take up Peter's seat. And, in the life of Sylvester the third, Eo enim Pontificatus devenerat, ut qui plus largitione & ambitione, non dico sanctitate vitae & doctrinae, valeret, is tantummodo bonis oppressis & rejectis obtineret: quem morem utinam aliquando non retinuissent nostra tempora; sed hos parum est, &c. The Papacie was come into this condition, that not he who was holiest and most learned, but he who gave maniest bribes and was most ambitious, obtained it, and that only by bearing down and casting at good men: which custom I wish our times had not retained; but this is little of it, &c. 2. There is grossness in their persons for adultery, cruelty, devilrie. John the 13. omnibus probris ac turpitudinibus à pueritiá contaminatus, venationibus, siquid temporis à libidinibus supererat, magis quam orationibus deditus. Hic sceleratissimus in adulterio comprehensus confossus fuit ; An infamous and vile man even from his infancy, what spare time he had from his lusts, was spent rather in Hunting than Prayer, at length he was stobbed in the very act of Adultery. Sylvester 2. malis artibus sedem adeptus, Diabolum socutus, cui se totum tradidorat, eâ lege Diaboli opem obtinuit, ut post mortem ejus totus esset ; Sylvester 2. having got the Papacie by unlawful ways, gave over himself to the devil, and got his help upon that condition that he should be his wholly after death. 3. Great cruelty in their poisoning, exhumating and beheading after death their predecessors, rescinding all their acts, So that in Steph. 5. Haec consuetudo invaluit, &c. See more in Chrystoph. 1. Boniface 7. Hildebrand and many others. 4. Innumerable schisms, some of them reckon 26. decided ordinarily by violence, and some of them with two or three Popes continuing many years, to say nothing of John the 8. whom Martin. and Plat. call a woman, who of child birth died in procession.
From what is said also we may gather, 1. That the Kingdom of Antichrist is not fully to be overturned by the Turks, but that there remaineth the greatest part undestroyed by that plague, upon which afterward the vials are poured forth, Chap. 16. God restraining and bounding that destruction for the Churches and Elects sake, which He had reserved, lurking amongst them.
2. We may see the tenaciousnesse of these men in not quiting their Idolatry, and repenting of their sins, which maketh way for the coming vials, under which also it is marked ( Chap. 16.9.) that they repented not, but went on in their blasphemies against God.
3. It appeareth, that the Idolatry and sins mentioned here, and the man who continue impenitently in them, are not to be understood of the idolatry and sins which the Pagan world is guilty of (whom God by this judgment aimeth not to reclaim!) but such sins as the backslidden Church of Antichrist is guilty of, that being the world, a third part whereof is destroyed, and two parts whereof, for a time, are spared, as is said, it being not the rest of men simply, but the rest of the men, which relate to the visible Church (the object of these plagues) as contradistinguished from the rest of the world. Beside, the idolatries, murders, &c. mentioned here, and the men who continue impenitent in them, are the same who are plagued by the last woe and last plagues or vials of the wrath of God; for, it is one continued controversy upon the same account, but the men plagued for Idolatry, murder, fornication, &c. by the vials, are the men who have the mark of the beast, Chap. 16.2. charged with the blood of Saints, ibid. verse. 6. Yea, the seat of the beast (untouched by this plague) ibid. verse. 10. found guilty also of Idolatry, sorcery and fornication, Chap. 13.1, 2, 4, 5. and Chap. 17.4, 5, 6, &c. Therefore they must be of one and the same Antichristian Church. For, seeing such men under such guilt, are found tenacious of the same impiety under the vials, although plagued by them, Whom can we esteem them to be but the men spoken of here under the same guilt, who being spared, and yet continuing therein, are of new brought unto a reckoning by the Lord? neither were it so wonderful to see Heathens continue in their idolatries after crosses, but it is wonderful to see Christians do so; more might have been expected from them.
4. Hence we may gather, that supposing the former trumpet, and Chap. 13.17. to relate to the Romish Church (for which the exposition of these places may be considered) and finding it true in the event, that the Romish Church, for a great part thereof, is overrun by the Turks ; yet the seat, and as it were a two part of that Kingdom to be spared, according to this prophesy, I say, we may gather, that the idolatry, sorcery, murder, &c. mentioned here, is to be inquired for among them, and that it is their worship, service and practices which are here so denominated by the Lord.
From what is said, we suppose it not needful to add many reasons why we have applied this plague to the Turks or Mohammedans, the consideration of what hath been laid down touching the object, nature, properties and effects of this sad woe, being compared in the event with the rise, progress, success and nature of the Turkish Empire; it will be found so evidently to be fulfilled in them, as will leave no ground to question it. Only let it be observed, that we conjoin the Saracens and Turks together as one; for, they possess the same parts of the world, did actually continue in one Dominion, do follow the same Religion, Laws and Customs, and do observe the same manner of proceeding in their Wars, with the same hatred of, and quarrel against Christians, &c. and seeing in the event what is prophesied here, is found exactly to be fulfilled in them, the considering of this prophesy, and the reading of their story, doth of itself make the application. And considering the great change and destruction that by Mahom • ts means hath been made especially in the Christian world, it is not like it would be omitted in this prophesy; and, there will be found no type so suitable, nor time so agreeable to it, as that of this trumpet.
This Mahomet lived a little before and about the 650. year (a little after Boniface the third had assumed the title of Universal Bishop ) he was an Arabian, a subtle fellow, and no Christian, about the 630. With the help of one Sergius a Nestorian Monk, and Johannes Antiochenus an Arian, and some Jews he began to coin his blasphemous Alcoran, wherein he endeavoreth a mixture of Paganism, Judaism, and Christianity, but of the grostest kind, to wit, Arianism and Nestorianism. It were long to rehearse all his tenets. He called himself the great prophet, and blasphemously applied some Scriptures to that purpose; he allegeth that his writings (to wit, what he calleth his Alfurca and Alcoran ) were given him from heaven, and are without error, and therefore joineth the Old Testament, the Gospel and the Alcoran together; he denieth the necessity of signs and wonders, but that the refusers of the Alcoran are to be persecuted with the sword, and yet that no man is to be persecuted for his Religion. To the receivers of the Alcoran be promiseth many great things, and asserteth it to be confirmed by many victories from the Lord; he asserteth One only true God, and denieth the Trinity of Persons, and absurdly asserteth a twofold personality of the God-head; he is against all Idols and Images, and allegeth himself to be specially commissionated against Idol-worship: and it may be that God having purposed him indeed to scourge that sin, hath also wisely ordered that, partly to make him the more instrumental in pursuing that sin, partly the more to convince and shame Christians that should be addicted to it. These things and such like may be more fully gathered from the Alcoran itself, and these who write of it. This is certain, that his monstrous absurdities became taking to many, and he himself to have great temporal power, especially on this occasion. Heraclius the Emperor in his wars against the Persians, had a considerable Army of Arabians in his service, who being dimitted after the war with reproachful speeches from their Officers, instead of pay, did fall to mutiny. Upon these this Mahomet so insinuated himself, that he was received to be their head (from this came the name of Saracens ; for, these Arabians being indeed Ishmaelits, and Hagarens, but accounting it a reproach to be descended of the bondwoman Hagar, to hide that, they claimed title to Sarah, and so assumed her name) after this Mahomet and they having prevailed in Arabia and settled in Mecha for a time, he left it, and invading Syria, settled the head of their dominion in Damascus. From this forward they speedily prevailed and did overrun many Kingdoms under the name of Saracens, yet were restrained from having footting in Europe, till after the Turks victory over them, they became of one Religion, under one head, for the further strengthening of their union. Since that time their dominion hath mightily increased under the name of Turks, so that now they are not restrained in the east as formerly, but do possess almost all the Grecian Empire, and parts of the western Empire also, yet have been keeped from overrunning Italy, it being like that these are not to be made use of by the Lord for that piece of service of darkening the Throne of the beast, which is reserved for another time.
If it should be objected here against this application, that these eastern parts of the Empire, over which the Turk hath prevailed, are such as have been least submissive to the Pope, and therefore this plague of the Turks may rather be looked on as a judgment on them for breaking unity with him, than as a plague upon him. Ans. This is indeed harped upon by some of the Papists, particularly by Bellarmine is his preface ad libros de Pontifice ; But will be clear by considering, 1. That once these Churches were professedly for the generality of them under him, the whole Christian world being admirers and worshippers of the beast, Chap. 13.8. and subject to the Pope, as they themselves used to boast. Now, there being so many Christians destroyed by the Turks, it must either infer a great destruction to be upon the Popish Kingdom, or it must be said, that a third part of the Christian world did not belong to him, which they will not willingly grant. 2. Suppose there was a withdrawing from his usurpation in part, yet these same Churches, being once infected with idolatry, error and superstition, by the Bishops of Rome, did still retain that leaven, till this judgment came upon them, and so in plaguing them for these evils, God gave warning to others lying in that same guilt. And that it pleased the Lord to begin with these eastern Churches rather than others, these reasons may be given, 1. Because he was not by these hands to overturn the beasts throne, but was to reserve a two part of that Kingdom, for other wise ends afterward. Therefore this west part of the world, is not first begun at. 2. In these eastern Churches Antichrists Kingdom and his corruptions had been most freely testified against and opposed, which made their guiltiness of after yielding to be the more inexcusable and ripe for judgment. 3. By scourging them first who seemed least accessory to the guilt, the Lord would evidence how displeasing any part of it is to Him, and the more to convince others who were deeper therein; and it is agreeable to this, that these plagued here, are only charged with such corruptions and sins of the Church of Rome, as these Churches were guilty of; and the two part now reserved, and after plagued by the vials, are beside these, charged with worshipping the beast and having his mark, Chap. 16.2. as if these did go a further length in the acknowledging of the absoluteness of the Pope than this third part, who are at the first reckoned with, did in that particular, though in the same guilt in respect of other corruptions. But lastly, it is clear that by this Turkish dominion a great part of the Romish power is eclipsed, and many of all orders, who had their dependence upon the Pope alone, were destroyed, whereof the war, called the holy war, is an evidence, besides the overthrow of many Kingdoms, Armies and Towns, who did directly own the Pope, and did not want his Holiness encouragement and benediction, with many consecrated Crosses, Swords, Banners, and the like, as pledges thereof: yea, not long before the ruin of that eastern Empire, diverse of the Emperors thereof, came purposely to be crowned at Rome, as acknowledging their dignity of the Pope; and ( Anno 1274.) Michael Emperor of Constantinople, promised to Pope Gregory the tenth the obedience of all the Grecian Churches: upon which grounds it is evident, that we may warrantably say that the tyranny of the Turks hath been a great plague to the Romish Ecclesiastic Kingdom, and that these who were destroyed by them, were generally accessory to the guilt of their corruptions.
Concerning the Idolatry of the Church of Rome.
IT may be of great concernment (and possibly of more difficulty) to clear this, that the Church of Rome by their worshipping of Images, relicts, and such like, even though they intend the worshipping of the true God, are yet notwithstanding really guilty of idolatry: and though it be not pertinent for this place to insist in it by a long digression; yet, (considering of what concernment it is for the clearing of this prophesy, and for warranting the application thereof to the Church of Rome, both in this Chapter and in many Chapters following) we think it necessary to lay down some things which may bear this application.
For the making out of this charge of Idolatry and worshipping of devils upon the Church of Rome, we shall first lay down what is such in the Scripture account. 2. What the Church of Rome doth practice concerning their Images and worship given to them. 3. Make out, that these practices are condemned in the Scripture, as worshipping of Idols the work of men's hands, &c. It is not our purpose to enlarge the first two, in speaking either of all the Idolatry which the Scripture condemneth, or yet of all the practices of the Church of Rome, which come in under this guilt, but so much as relateth to Images especially.
For the first, The Scriptures reckon and condemn a twofold Idolatry in reference to Images. 1. When the Image itself is accounted God and worshipped as such. This Idolatry is properly against the first Command, and is generally condemned in the practice of the Heathen.
The second sort of Idolatry, is, when the Images themselves are not worshipped, as having any Godhead properly in themselves; but as they relate to, represent, and are made use of in the worship of Him who is accounted God, so that the motive moving to worship, is pretended respect to the God represented by them, which we will find both amongst Heathens and amongst the people of God, the one worshipping the Images of their Idols, not as gods themselves, but as intending to worship their gods in these, and by these; yet are they commonly condemned in the Scripture, not only for worshipping their supposed gods, but for worshipping the Images whereby they did represent them; the other, to wit, the people of God, professing to worship the true God, and yet for doing it by Images, and to Images, are condemned for worshiping of Images themselves, as the after instances will clear.
This sort of idolatrous worship may be two ways tried,
1. When we worship him with such worship as Idolaters used to their Idols. Thus the representing of the true God by Images, making high places and groves to Him, are condemned, Deut. 4.15, 16, 25. and Deut. 12. verse. 31, 32. and 2 Chron. 33. verse. 17. where, sacrificing in the high places, though to the Lord their God, is marked as a relict of their Idolatry.
2. It may be tried by this, when religious worship alone due to God, is given to anything which is not the true God, though it were to instruments and means appointed by Himself: such Idolatry is condemned in Cornelius, Act. 10. and in John, Revel. 19. and the people's going a whoring after the brazen Serpent (much more when that worship is given to anything which is not made use of in the worship of God by His appointment, as Images of Angels, Saints, or of the Lord Himself) Thus it had been Idolatry under the Old Testament, to have worshipped the Tables of stone, Pot of Manna, Moses Rod, Paschal Lamb, or such things ordinarily or extraordinarily made use of by God. These properly come under the second Command, whereby we are discharged, not only to worship false gods, or Images as gods; but also are inhibited to worship the true God any way not prescribed by Him, but especially by Images.
If it be questioned what this Religious worship is, we take it up thus,
1. That worship which the Scripture only appropriateth to the true God, as praying and vowing to Him, swearing by His Name, building Temples, Altars, &c. seeking the restoring of health and such like.
2. We call that Religious worship, which Idolaters use to give to their supposed gods, such as to kiss an Image, Hos. 13.2. to sacrifice and burn incense to them, set lights before them, and appoint Priests for them, Judge. 17. and of this sort was that Idolatry ( Act. 14.) of offering sacrifices to Paul and Barnabas ; for, these things have ever been counted Religious by men, and given to Idols upon that account, neither ever hath it been or can it be given to Images upon another account.
3. When the worship is not civil, it must be accounted Religious, as may be gathered from the circumstances thereof, as if the act, end and other circumstances be Religious, the action or worship itself must be so also; as it is one thing to bow the knee in a salutation to a man, it is another thing to bow in prayer, and that before an Image, to do it occasionally, and in such place, and purposely, as a piece of Religion and worship; to bow the knee at a table or before an Image, is one thing, but to do it before an Image, set up for a Religious end at a table, upon which Christ is esteemed to be really present, is another.
That we may be distinct in the second, we shall, 1. consider what is the practice of Papists. 2. What is their Doctrine concerning this sort of worship, and that in so far as is uncontroverted by them.
1. We will find infinite numbers of Images framed for the worship of God, and of the persons of the Godhead, distinctly, of the Virgin Marie, the Cross, Angels, Saints, &c. 2. We will find them in their practice giving great worship to all these, kneeling to them, discovering themselves before them, offering oblations, and putting up prayers to them, building Temples, and sanctifying of them by these, carrying them in processions, &c. 3. We will find a worship given to Angels and Saints in a high degree; as praying, dedicating of Temples, swearing by them, seeking their intercession: of such kind are to the virgin Marie, as followeth, Ora pro nobis, sancta Dei genitrix, ut digni efficiamur promissionibus Christi. Dulcis amica Dei, rosa vernans, stella decora, iu memor est • mei dum mortis venerit hora. Ave, santissima mater Dei, regina Coeli, porta Paradisi, Domina mundi, libera me ab omni malo, ora pro peccato meo, that is, O holy Mother of God, pray for us, that we may be made worthy of the promises of Christ. Sweet friend of God, the pleasant Rose, and glorious Star, be mindful of me when the hour of death shall come. Hail, most holy Mother of God, the Queen of Heaven, the port of Paradise, the lady of the world, deliver me from all evil, pray for my sin. And infinite numbers of this kind to be gathered from the Roman Breviarie, that is called Psalterium Marianum ; a compend whereof, is set down by Chemnitz in his Examen of the Council of Trent, part. 3. de veneratione sanctorum & corum invocation. So are also their prayers to other Saints, as to Elizabeth; Eia, mater, nos agnosce, &c. O Mother, acknowledge us, &c. To Nicolas; Credo, sancte Nicolas, tuis me procibus esse salvandum, id • o te clamo, &c. Serva me supplicem famulum tuum, amice Dei Nicolae, de praesentibus angustiis & tribulationibus, quia in te confidit anima mea, ut per t • me salvet qui te sibi elegit. I believe, holy Nicolas, to be saved by thy prayers, therefore I cry upon thee, &c. O Nicolas, the friend of God, save me thy humble servant from my present straits and tribulations, because my soul trusteth in thee, that He who hath chosen thee to Himself may save me through thee. Sancta Dorothea, cor mundum in me crea ; Holy Dorothie, creat in me a clean heart: and hundreds of that kind. Yea, it is that length, that the Jesuits do monthly (as Lorinus in 1. Act. asserteth) cast lots what Saint to choose for their Patron, for the month ensuing. Luther pronounced this sort of Idolatry to be the cause of the Turks War against Christendom, as in vita ajus apud Melch. Adam.
4. Beside what worship is given to Saint • and their Images, there is also a worshipping of the material Cross, Nails and other things made use of in our Lord's suffering, and of the Images of that Cross, of the Saints Relics, and Cloaths of the Sacrament of the Altar or Mass, or the Hoast, as they call it; these they adore, to these (especially the Cross) they direct their prayers, as, O crux, ave, spes unica, hoc passionis tempore, Auga piis justitiam reisque dona veniam. Hail O Cross, my only hope, in this time of Christ's suffering, increase in the Godly righteousness, and grant pardon to sinners. This is brought in by Aquinas, 3. part. 4. art. quast. 25. as the ground whereby he pleadeth the highest degree of divine Worship to the Cross; because that song is used in the Church, insisted on also by Bonaventura, lib. 3. insententias, ad distinct. 9:
These practices (and innumerable moe) are the practices not of a few particular persons, but are contained in the public Liturgies of their Churches, we shall now inquire in their Doctrine concerning these practices, wherein we will not find them so unanimous: our enquiry is especially concerning the worshipping of Images.
1. They do generally agree, that Images of all these sorts may be made, and being made, ought to be worshipped with more than civil Worship, and with respect to these represented by them. And though this be determined by the second Council of Nice, formerly mentioned, and again ratified in their late Council of Trent, as may be seen in the acts thereof; yet are they not one among themselves in defining the nature of this Worship. Their prime Schoolmen, Aquinas, part. 3. quast. 25. Bonaven. lib. 3. • ist. 9. and others their followers, give to the Image that same worship which they give to that which is represented by it, to wit, to the Images of God and to the Cross, they give that which they call 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 ; to the Image of the Virgin Mary 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 , a worship above what is given to other Saints; to the Images of Saints 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 itself. Upon this ground (cited out of Aristotle ) that honor done to the type, honoreth him that is typified. And they labor to vindicate themselves from Idolatry by this distinction, that these Images may be considered, either, 1. respectu materiae, as they are of Gold, Silver, &c. Or, 2. respectus formae & significationis, as they signify and represent; the first way they honor them not, but the second, say they. Ergo, &c. In which distinction we conceive the Heathen themselves would acquies • e; for, no Gold or Silver was worshipped by them, but as in such a form, and as under such a signification.
Again, Durand. (who hath not many followers in this, and is marked to be a special opposer of Thomas his Doctrine) though he asserteth that worship is to be given to the Images; yet saith, that it is not properly given to them, but to what is represented by them, so as our adoring of the Image, is the adoring of Him brought to our memory by the Image, as if He were present. Thus he, Lib. 3. distinct. 9. Quast. 2.
3. The later Writers, who would seem more subtle, as Bellar. Gregor. de Valent. &c. look upon these former two opinions as extremes, the one giving too much, and the other too little to Images. Therefore Gregor. de Valent. in 3. disp. 6. quaest. 11. punct. 6. doth condemn Durand for this alswell, though not in the same degree, as he doth the Heretics. Their judgment is (although even they differ, Gregor. de Valent. being nearer Thomas than the other, yet both account it proper worship) that the Images should be truly and properly worshipped with Religious worship (relatively, as they call it) that is, with respect to the thing represented. Thus in one act of worship, they worship both the Image and the thing signified, with a worship suitable, but not equal, and the same with that which is given to what is signified; as for instance, in worshipping the image of God, they worship God represented by the Image with the highest degree of honor; they worship the Image also properly, but not with the same honor, because they worship God for Himself, His Image for Him, and not for itself. Again, the Image of the Virgin Mary, is worshipped with true worship, but inferior to what is given to herself for the reason foresaid, and also inferior to what is given to the Image of God, but beyond what worship is given to the Image of any other Saint, because she herself is inferior to God, though superior to other Saints. This manner of worship they illustrate by an example; as suppose a great Courtier to be made Commissioner and Ambassador for his Prince, he is received and honored with all Kingly reverence due to him, whose Person he sustains; in this, say they, that honor is principally given to the King, who is honored in his Ambassador, as if he himself were present, yet truly and properly the Ambassador may be said to be so reverenced, and to have all that honor done to him, as he filleth that room by representing his King, and, as such, he is really and truly honored also; even so, say they, is it here. The honor of the thing represented is principally aimed at, yet so as for that end the Image representing is really and truly honored with that same worship which should be given to him that is represented if he were present, only it is not for its self, and so in that respect inferior. Neither do they esteem this to be Idolatry; because they esteem Idolatry to consist in this, the giving of Divine worship to the creature after that same manner, and upon the same account that is given to God. And therefore, although they give the same Divine worship to the Image which they give to God in itself, yet seeing they give it not upon that account, as if the image were God, and for itself, but relatively, Therefore can it not be Idolatry, because they never conjoin these two together, (as Gregor. de Valent. ibid. ut supra, expresseth it, ut & cultum divinum usurpent, & illum qua ration Deo exhiberi debeat, tribuant creatura, hoc est, ipsis imaginibus secundum se (and, as a little after, sicut Deo ) and therefore, illi ejusmodi adoratione nunquam committunt idolatriam.
It is generally granted further by the forcited Authors, that the making of Images to God, was simply prohibited under the Old Testament, and that there is nothing under the New Testament to establish this worship, but that it is grounded upon tradition, and the Churches determination confirmed by a famous tradition of the Lord's sending His own portraictour to Abagarus ; and of Luke's painting the Lord and His Mother, which are amongst their unanswerable arguments for establishing this worship. Therefore when that horned argument is propounded, Either Images are warranted by the Word or not; If they be warranted by the Word, that warrant is to be produced: if not, then are they not to be valued. Eccius, answering to this in his Enchiridion, doth no way offer to instruct their warrant from the Word, but asserteth many things in practice to be warranted by tradition, such as is for this. If then we make out this, that such • orshipping of Images, notwithstanding of such exceptions, be condemned in Scripture, as Idolatry, we have what we proposed, and if this can be gathered from the foresaid grounds laid down by their most coutelous Doctors, what might be collected from the principles of their superstitious Mor • ks and practices of ignorant people, especially if they were considered as in the time of darkness, before the light of Reformation made them alter many expressions? Cassander, speaking of their worshipping of Images, saith, Consult, deimag. that these Images were more or less reverently worshipped as they were more or less gorgeously appareled, and that these which should have drawn others from these superstitions, proved to be the Authors thereof themselves, that ( quaestus causa ) they did nourish them among the people.
Argument 1. If the Heathens who believed an invisible God-head, be yet found guilty of this idolatry of worshipping stocks and stones, &c. because they worshipped Images of such matter, even though they professed the worshipping of the God represented by these, and did disclaim the acknowledging of these Images to be their gods, or of worshipping them as such, but with relation to the God represented by them: Then this worshipping of Images amongst the Papists must be so also, notwithstanding of their exceptions: But the former is true. Therefore the latter must be true also.
The connection of the major cannot but hold; for, if they be found guilty not only of worshipping the Idols represented by their Images, but also the Images themselves, because they worshipped their gods as represented in and by these images, so must the Papists be accounted worshippers of Images upon that same account; for, a quatenus ad omne, valet consequentia.
It cannot be said, that the worshipping of Images among the Heathen is only condemned as Idolatry, because they made Images to represent false gods, or because they represented the true God by unsuitable Images, as of an Ox that eateth grass, Psal. 106. For, 1. Idolatry and making of Images at the beginning, was not with respect to false gods, but was a degenerating from, and corrupting of the worship of the true God, as may be gathered from Rom. 1.23. where it is said of the Gentiles, that knowing God they worshipped Him not as God, but changed His glory, not the glory of an Idol, into the similitude, &c. and it is like, this corrupting of the worship of the true God made way for the altering of the very object of their worship, as an effect of the Reprobate mind which followed. Something of this also may be gathered from Acts 17. in Paul's dispute at Athens. This exception then would not serve to convince these, whom yet the Scripture condemneth. a. We answer, that the connection will hold even in reference to these who represented false gods, suppose Jupiter, Diana, Apollo, and such, because they were not only charged with worshipping these Idols, Jupiter, Apollo, Baal, &c. which were not the work of men's hands, but they are also charged with worshipping the works of their own hands, and images of these Idols, whom they pretended to worship by these representations, and adorations before them; and therefore the ratio à pari, will hold in this, that if these exceptions did not liberate them from the charge of worshipping their Images the work of their hands, So neither will it be effectual to exempt the Papists, because the Argument runneth not to prove them to represent false gods by their Images, but that the worship done to the Image (though pretended to be done to another) is also counted a worshipping of the Images themselves before God.
The other exception is of that same nature: for, the Scripture condemeneth not worshipping of God in Images, because they were Images of unreasonable creatures only, but simply, because they were Images: Rom. 1. they are charged, that they changed the Glory of the incorruptible God, to the Image of corruptible man; and Augustine, de civitare Dei, cleareth out of Varro, lib. 7. cap. 5. that the Gentiles portraicted their gods in man's picture chiefly, though they were invisible, because man's soul is likest to them, and man's body being the vessel of the soul, is therefore the fittest Image to represent them, yet can it not be said, but that cometh still to be Idolatry.
The weight then of this Argument will • y in the Assumption, to wit, that even these Heathens who are charged with worshipping Images in Scripture the work of their hands, did yet solemnly disclaim their accounting these Images to be gods, but that they worshipped them for the honor of the God whom they represented. This appeareth, 1. by considering these places of Scripture, Rom. 1.21. Acts 17. where the Apostles dispute runneth to condemn that opinion, That the unknow God ignorantly worshipped by them, could be worshipped by men's hands, verse. 28. that is to say, by making of Images, or could be represented by silver or gold, or any other thing, verse. 29. And although their thoughts of God might be more gross, yet this is ever true, that they accounted not their images to be the God whom they worshipped, and so did not worship them for themselves (or, secundum se ) but relatively with respect to others also. Act. 19.35. express difference is put betwixt Diana and her Images, and the silver shrines that were made to her, and Jupiter is asserted to be in heaven, and therefore was distinctly considered by them from the Images they made unto him.
2. It will appear from reason, if we consider that they placed their gods in Heaven. 2. That they had many Images of one God. 3. That they often changed their Images, but not their gods. 4. That many whom they worshipped by Images, were once such as had been living in the world, unto whose honor they erected such Images, but could never nor did never suppose them to be the persons themselves.
3. It will appear from the Heathens own disputings and assertions, whereby they shifted that absurdity of worshipping the works of their hands; yet is it by the Fathers, on this ground, born in upon them. See August. in Psal. 113. ( nobis 115.) where, having asked the Question, why the Scripture insisteth so much to clear that the Images of the Gentiles can neither speak nor hear, &c. which could not but be known to a child? the reason is, saith he, Because by erecting such Images, people are ready to conceive some Godhead to be in them. Hence when they were pressed with this absurdity of worshipping the work of their hands, they did deny it, saying, that they worshipped not the Image, but the numen or God which dwelt in it, and was represented by it, and that after its dedication. If some of them were pressed further, that that numen or god was but a devil, they would answer, nec simulachrum nec daemonium colo, sed per effigiem corporalem ejus rei signum intueor quam colere debeo ; I neither worship an Idol nor a devil, but by a bodily Image I behold the sign of that thing which I should worship. If Christians pressed yet further, that the things represented were but creatures as Tellus, Neptune, Vulcan, Lucifer, &c. or some Star, or this or that creature which was a body, yet, saith he, they durst answer, non se ipsa corpora colere, sed quae illis regendis praesident numina ; that they worshiped not the creatures, but the gods that ruled in them. In consideration whereof, he citeth that place, Rom. 1. of changing the truth of God into a lie, and serving the creature more than the Creator, as if by the first part, the Apostle did condemn Images of God, and by the second their interpretations of the worship given to them, because it is there counted a serving of the creature whatever their pretext was; for (saith he) who, praying or worshipping, beholding an Image, is not so affected as if he thought to be heard by it, and hoping to have what he desireth performed by it? Therefore (saith he) men involved in such superstitions, turn themselves to pray to that Image which they call the Sun, or Neptune, &c. as if they could affect them with their sighings, and give that same respect to them as to the thing signified by them, and pray to the Image before they pray to the thing itself. This (saith he) cometh and someway is extorted by that visible Image, as thinking that readiest to hear which it in shape likest to ourselves, &c. where many other things are further to this purpose. Also, in Psal. 96. ( nobis, 97.) where he bringeth in the Heathen giving this answer, Non illud colo seu adora quod video, sed servio ei quem non video, quis est iste? Numen quoddam invisibile quod praesides illi simulachro : where they distinguish betwixt adoro and servio, as Papists do between 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 and 〈 in non-Latin alphabet 〉 . If it were objected further to these heathens, that they worshipped devils, they would answer. They worshipped good Angels and virtutes Dei. It is replied in the same place, If they worshipped good Angels, they would reject their worship, as that Angel did to John, Rev. 19, &c. This way of shifting also may be found in Lactantius, de origin erroris, Lib. 2. Cap. 2. apud. Chrylost. in Eph. 5. hom. 18. From all which we may gather, that the heathens wanted not the same shifts for excusing their worshipping of Images, yet was it still charged upon them, that they worshipped Idols which neither saw nor heard, &c. although still they denied it.
2. Thus we argue: If the people of Israel were accounted guilty of Idolatry and worshipping of devils, and the works of their hands, because of their worshipping Images, which they professedly erected to the true God, and even when they pretended the abhorring of false gods, and the adhering unto the true God, Then must the same guilt be justly charged upon the Papists, who worship Images, as is said; But the former is true. Ergo, &c. The connection of the major dependeth on this, that the inhibition of Idolatry and manner of worshipping God under the New Testament, is as strict and spiritual as it was under the Old. And therefore these who say that such making of Images of the Godhead and worshipping them, was unlawful before Christ's coming, but now is made lawful, must show some repeal of that Law, before that can be granted. Beside, these Images being pleaded-for as Books for the rude and ignorant, it is unreasonable to say, that there is more use of such Books under the light of the Gospel, than during the Law which stood in types.
The weight of this also will lie then upon the Assumption, to wit, that the people of Israel were charged with Idolatry in their worshipping of Images, even then when they pretended the worshipping of the true God by them. For clearing this, we shall consider these four Instances, 1. Exod. 32. 2. That of Micah, Judge. 17. 3. That Idolatry of Ieroboans which the Tribes of Israel continued long in. 4. That worshipping in the high places, condemned in the Tribe of Judah, 2. Chron. 33.17. In all which places, we suppose these two to be clear, 1. That these worshippers intended not the worshipping of false gods, or of the Images which they had made, but to worship the true God by these. And, 2. that yet they are still condemned as Idolaters, and that sin of Ioroboam's is expressly called worshipping of devils, 2 Chron. 11.15. For the first instance, Exod. 32. it is clear, 1. that they were not utterly forgetful of the true God, though practically that might be charged upon them, especially considering Aaron's uncontroverted going alongst with them. 2. That that Image is called JEHOVAH, which brought them out of Egypt ; which being a deliverance past, before these Image had a being, must certainly be understood to be the representation of that God which brought them out of the Land of Egypt. 3. It can hardly be thought they should have esteemed these to be gods themselves, and so soon to have passed from them. 4. The service is service to the Lord, verse. 5. To morrow is a feast (not to the Calf ) but to JEHOVAH. The worship performed, ( verse. 6.) is not that which they used to give to Idols, but to the Lord Himself; the people's end in requiring it, that they might have something to supply the want of Moses presence by some visible sign, and to have these to go up before them to Canaan whether the Lord called them and not back again to Egypt, doth make it appear, that their sin charged on them ( verse. 8.) of turning out of the way, looketh to point out their failing to have been in their manner of worshipping the true God by an unwarrantable mean, especially if we compare this with Acts 7.40, 41, 42. where this Idolatry is made the cause of God's giving them up to worship the host of Heaven. Now, by Stephen's arguing, the worshipping the host of Heaven must be Idolatry of a grosser nature, than that committed by the Israelites, Exod. 32. and yet if their Idolatry was professed worshipping of the calves as gods, it will be found more gross than to worship the host of Heaven, at least there can be no such sensible gradation of heightening that Spiritual plague of worshipping the host of Heaven beyond the other, which is Stephen's scope; therefore it is thus to be understood, that because they corrupted the worship of the true God, contrary to His command, therefore God gave them up to the worshipping of these that are not gods, such as the host of Heaven; which way of justice, was formerly observed in reference to the Gentiles from Rom. 1, &c. So that the construction put upon their deed, ( Acts. 7.41.) is the Lord's estimation of it and not their own profession, and that the Israelites intended the worship of the true God in these calves, Bellarmine thinketh it not improbable, de imag. lib. 2. cap. 13.
The second instance is in Micah's practice, Judge. 17. where it is clear, that they counted not that Idol to be God, but intended the worship of the true God by it: for ( verse. 3.) the mother saith she had dedicated that money to the Lord, to make a graven and molten Image, intending expressly to honor the Lord, in bestowing so much on that Image for him: For she first dedicateth the money to Him, and then bestoweth it (as it were) for His use upon that Image. 2. It appeareth by Micah's great zeal to have a Levite to be his Priest, and his joy when he obtained it, and his promising himself a blessing from the Lord upon that account; which certainly supponeth, that he intended good service to JEHOVAH in the doing of that, verse. 13. And lastly, we find that Priest enquiring counsel for the Danits ; not from the Image, but from the Lord: whereby it appeareth, that they intended not the setting up of new gods, but the honoring of the Lord and confirming of themselves by visible signs of His presence.
The third instance, is, that of Jeroboam, 1 King. 12. 2 Chron. 11. in his infamous sin of setting up calves at Dan and Bethel, whereby he made Israel to sin: that this is most gross Idolatry and worshipping of devils, the Scripture frequently holdeth forth. Yet, 2. that it was not Jeroboam's design to withdraw the people from the true God Himself, to the worshipping of these calves as God, but allanerly by corrupting the manner of His worship to set up these visible signs of His presence in place of these appointed by Himself at Jerusalem, will also appear, if we consider, 1. Jereboam's motive, inducing him to this sin: it was not for fear the people should worship the true God, or to prevent that; but it was for fear of the people's going to Jerusalem, and to prevent that: hence his pretext is not to put these calves in the room of the God worshipped at Jerusalem, but to equal Dan and Bethel with these visible signs to Jerusalem according to his saying, It is too much for you to go up to Jerusalem, as if he would say, ye may worship God nearer home in these places designed. Neither is it likely, that he could have so expected to have effectuated his interprise by proposing a change in the object of their worship. 2. It will appear from this, that that Idolatry of Jeroboam is not only distinguished from the true worship of God continued for a time in Judah ; but also from the Iolatry of Heathens abroad, and Idolatrous Kings succeeding to him, such as that of Ahab. 1 King. 16. 30, &c. (who yet it seemeth wanted not all profession of worshipping the true God) Iereboam's Idolatry is counted light in respect of Ahab, and no other reason can be given, but because Ahab, and these Sidonians, whom he followed, erred in setting up strange gods; and Jeroboam his error did consist in setting up strange worship to the true God: and when Jehu is commended for destroying the Idolatry of Ahab (2 Kings Chap. 9. and 10.) it cannot be thought, that he changed only the worshipping of Baal into the worshipping of Jeroboam's calf, without respect to the true God. For, 1. what less abomination were it to worship the image of a calf than the image of Baal. 2. That could not consist with John's fair professions of zeal for the Lord, if he had not thought the worshipping of these calves (upon the former politick consideration of Jeroboam ) consistent with worshipping of the true God, 2 King. 10.31. John's challenge, is, that he took not heed to walk in the Law of the Lord with all his heart; for, he departed not from the sins of Jeroboam : which words imply, that John had some profession of worshipping the true God, but was not sincere in the manner of it; which phrase is also sometimes spoken of sundry Kings of Judah.